Child Parading as a Vector of Sympathy & Leniency Farming + Art Plagiarism Case #35-36 - @Daio - Kristina Zhuravleva - Кристина Журавлева

in #utopian-io5 years ago (edited)

2017-05-10-18-54-47-900x646.jpg
Source

In today's post we will explore the subject of what we came to call -for lack of a better phrase- Child Parading, which is (to be a bit more descriptive) a sort of child exploitation that manipulates the viewer/curator into a cognitive bias not unlike, in essence, to the Halo Effect via the systematic featuring of a child, in order to elicit sympathy, with the intent of transforming that induced sympathy into votes and rewards.

The human vulnerability to be manipulated into such cognitive bias via the exploitation of children is age old and well known for example amongst the panhandling/beggar scene of any major city, since individuals in these scenes and similar ones quickly discover -either via observation of others or by chance- that people are much more inclined to help them when they are in the company of a child.

Within law enforcement circles the same technique is known to be used in various situations, particularly by single parents, as in example when engaging in shoplifting, it is a sort of "get out of jail free" card, officers sent to deal with such cases routinely give the offender a free pass, in part influenced by the sympathy the child elicits and in part to skip the heavy and complex paperwork that arresting the sole and exclusive legal guardian of a minor entails.

There is no need to make an exhaustive list of case examples in which this principle is exemplified, the two examples above suffice to communicate to the reader the type of exploitation we are referring to. To summarize, there are an infinitude of circumstances in which children are intentionally used as shields, "get out of jail free" cards, as Halos and as tools to elicit sympathy and benevolence that would not be obtained otherwise were the presence of the child not provided.

As you might have surmised this psychological vulnerability and exploit can and is used by certain actors in Steem to manipulate curators into rewarding their posts. It is also used to manipulate antiabuse operators (cleaners) into providing extra or unlimited leniency when abuse is detected.

Let's see now, in practice how this exploitative manipulation takes place in the platform.

The Case of @Daio

You might be familiar due to previous posts with the case of @daio, but just in case you are not let us give you a brief summary.

Daio is one of the few remaining parts of the Yanik/Arthur/dman57 Plagiarism Ring, one of the biggest if not the biggest plagiarism rings Steem has seen.

Her story in the platform is a fairy tale similar to the one of @andrianna in that their accounts were opened by the Yanik ring and then supposedly sold to them. That fairy tale is debunked in the link above in the case of @andrianna and here you have her admitting it was all a lie a few days ago, admitting that she didn't buy the account -as she deceived the whole community including top witnesses into believing-, admitting that she was a collaborator, partner, asset of the Yanik plagiarism ring from the start, and is supposedly no longer one.

The case of @daio is very peculiar, she was detected engaging in plagiarism here, here, here and here, blatantly copying photographic artwork with no permission from the authors and with no credit or attribution whatsoever, effectively taking credit for the whole composition/motive of the artwork when in fact her reproductions are merely copies. In one case here she was even caught copying another painters artwork and claiming as fake source a photograph.

Her bizarre excuses went even up to the limits of claiming that photographers are not artists and they do not deserve nor are owed any credit or attribution when doing reproductions of their work. Yes, you heard that right, according to @daio: Photographers are not artists and deserve no credit or attribution!!!...

The @daio account is also demonstrably operated by the same person operating the @yakubenko/ @dasha193 accounts, one of the main operators of the Yanik plagiarism ring aka Dashulya Yakubenko aka Dasha Artamonova.

Here is the evidence that shows the @daio account is operated by the same person operating the @yakubenko account (now blacklisted by @Cheetah and @SteemCleaners for belonging to that plagiarism/scamming ring):

@daio makes a comment in reply to a question made to @yakubenko in her post
876876ggjjg.png
https://steemd.com/tx/af977197a9dc86e5e44f3b7b783a15c29bba7635

@daio deletes that comment 9 seconds after making it
oy98y8y8y8y.png
https://steemd.com/tx/d83cf2171cc20a52190dda2212a3c82845088fb4

@yakubenko makes the exact same comment 96 seconds after the deletion
89y7986yhv.png
https://steemd.com/tx/ed9b996ecdaf1ca0601ca0fd64f2b887b461ee70

Source

Child Parading as a Shield to Elicit Leniency

Right after these plagiarism cases as well as her connections to the Yanik plagiarism ring began coming to light, we noted a marked thematic transformation in her blog, all of a sudden her blog morphed from an art blog ridden with art plagiarism, to one of a loving mother that shares pictures of her son at every possible chance, mixed with art plagiarism. Namely, when the heat was turn on the blog rapidly switched from art plagiarism to child parading mixed with art plagiarism, in a calculated maneuver to elicit sympathy, forgiveness, leniency, exceptionalism.

Here are the 22 child parading posts in the last 3 months:

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26104906.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26105048.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26105130.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26105228.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26105322.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26105408.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26105513.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26105556.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26105634.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26105726.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26105806.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26105903.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26105949.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26110051.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26110134.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26110345.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26110134kjjkhkjh.jpg
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26110554.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26110706.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26110938.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26111027.png
Source

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26111159.png
Source

Art Plagiarism Case #35

And then, 3 days ago after dozens of warnings to cite sources of "her" artwork and to stop engaging in art plagiarism, the user posted this:

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26124548.png
Source

Post's URL / URL del post:
https://steemit.com/art/@daio/my-new-picture-acrylic

F2oe6wGy.jpg

screenshotsteemit.com2019.06.26124719.png
Source

tumblr_na6sd3xe3U1spnyg9o1_500.jpg
Source

Source of the Art Plagiarism / Fuente del Plagio Artístico:
https://www.eyeem.com/p/56949546

Yesterday

368La1qZAv72XavRopT69yjj9q68qfnTU3qzLFhVG.jpg
Yesterday's @daio's post

Today: Art Plagiarism Case #36

n7CKsLLU.jpg

Post's URL / URL del post:
https://steemit.com/art/@daio/this-comment-amused-you-should-be-ashamed-not-to-know-and-at-the-same-time-argue-with-me

USgKoryE83j2wozjKuanzG7qDi3EHwhtSZrF1gDC8qBREFoiEtMBabH98nzx5nBLU5h6r5HyQJ7M6z5pehh9tS.jpg
Source

Here you can see the user tracing the whole source:
368La1qZAv72XavRopT69yjj9q68qfnTU3qzL7Dgw3gxEadMD3m5YpGpvN4KpUmKFCDsCPyHiVHXWRJrhYAWNzbx.jpg
Source

As you can see the the user deceives curators and viewers into thinking she is making a version of the Gioconda, a version supposedly out of her own imagination. When in reality the user is plagiarizing another author's version of the Gioconda.

olbinskimonalisa.jpg
Source

Source of the Art Plagiarism / Fuente del Plagio Artístico:
https://americangallery.wordpress.com/2010/09/29/rafal-olbinski-1945/
Author: Rafal Olbinski

This is Jaguar Force,
Reporting directly from the Jungle.
Onwards!

Sort:  

Howdy @jaguar.force,

Good job connecting the dots and informing us of these connection. I commend you for your persistence. It's almost like a dog that has a bone and they just won't let go of... except that dog is a jaguar. 🐈

I had a few questions concerning this submission for clarity. I recommend placing particular emphasis on these things for the reader's understanding and empowerment in antiabuse.

1. Based on the information provided, what is the course of action proposed to the reader? How can they help? If we hope to solicit the power of the community, we need to advise them accordingly.

2. Aside from corrective action, what are some recommendations as to how this may be prevented in the future. What actions can we take now?

I know this ring has been operating for some time per your reports. I look forward to the day we can close this chapter and move on to the next objective but abusers have a tendency to be persistent so I'm not certain of that prospect.

Your contribution has been evaluated according to Utopian policies and guidelines, as well as a predefined set of questions pertaining to the category.

To view those questions and the relevant answers related to your post, click here.


Need help? Chat with us on Discord.

[utopian-moderator]

Thank you for your review, @anthonyadavisii! Keep up the good work!

Hi @jaguar.force!

Your post was upvoted by @steem-ua, new Steem dApp, using UserAuthority for algorithmic post curation!
Your post is eligible for our upvote, thanks to our collaboration with @utopian-io!
Feel free to join our @steem-ua Discord server

What right do you have to lure my child into it?
Do you know who you are after this? You shit!

I forbid to use my photos! Especially photos of my son !!!
Stop monetizing my photos and photos of my son !!!

Hey, @jaguar.force!

Thanks for contributing on Utopian.
We’re already looking forward to your next contribution!

Get higher incentives and support Utopian.io!
Simply set @utopian.pay as a 5% (or higher) payout beneficiary on your contribution post (via SteemPlus or Steeditor).

Want to chat? Join us on Discord https://discord.gg/h52nFrV.

Vote for Utopian Witness!

This post earned a total payout of 29.711$ and 22.339$ worth of author reward which was liquified using @likwid. To learn more.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.20
TRX 0.26
JST 0.039
BTC 100331.97
ETH 3646.26
USDT 1.00
SBD 3.05