14 Truths About Trolls - Stats & Analysis Behind The Madness

in #steemit8 years ago (edited)

What's The Deal With Trolls? Why Do they Exist?



First of all I would like to credit my main source of information that I used in this article. John Rampton - 15 Truths About Online Trolls for entrepreneur.com, but I would also like to offer my own insight into the dark realm of trolls.

First before I continue I have to define what a troll is. As per wikipedia (I think it is alright to quote wikipedia for a general overview)

"An internet troll is a person who sows discord on the Internet by starting arguments or upsetting people, by posting inflammatory, extraneous, or off-topic messages in an online community (such as a newsgroup, forum, chat room, or blog) with the deliberate intent of provoking readers into an emotional response or of otherwise disrupting normal on-topic discussion, often for their own amusement."

With the recent purge of visibility of many of the trolls who were starting to pop up, I felt it would be interesting to take a look at some of the statistics and reasons that trolls even exist. Some things you may already be familiar with, but hopefully you will learn quite a bit as well, as most of us have probably never stopped to put ourselves in the shoes (probably large and grungy) of an internet troll.

14 Interesting Tidbits About Trolls

1. The term troll encapsulates a number of different behaviors on the internet

There are trolls who just like to disrupt the flow of a chat on a forum for fun, but there are also trolls who are hateful, malicious or just spam a forum/social media account with repeated posting of meaningless drivel (not unlike some of the spam bots that were posting in every introduceyourself post). There are also trolls that are genuinely funny, an example to me are those who when asked on youtube what song is this reply "Darude - Sandstorm." While not causing any real harm, this is essentially a minor if humorous form of trolling. Realizing the different types of trolls should allow you to respond or not respond at all.

2. Trolls tend to have “Dark Tetrad” personality traits

According to psychologists Erin Buckels, Paul Trapnell and Delroy Paulhus “trolling correlated positively with sadism, psychopathy, and Machiavellianism,” which are a part of the “Dark Tetard” of personality traits. “Sadism means delighting in the harm of others, psychopathy is an antisocial personality disorder, and Machiavellianism means a person’s tendency to be unemotional and deceitful.” So essentially the trademarks of a troll are those who show little emotion, are loners, and enjoy harming others (in this case through verbal abuse or degradation).

3. You or your friends may be a troll or have trolled

According to a YouGov study of 1,125 adults, “28 percent percent of Americans admitted (to) malicious online activity directed at somebody they didn’t know.” That's over one in four for this study (and the number may be higher since you never know exactly how truthful people may be). A lot of this is done to strangers with whom people may either dislike or just wish to agitate, possibly without anyone really knowing your true identity

4. You may not actually be dealing with a troll

Some people who you may think are trolls are actually just strongly opinionated people. Just because the way they say something might seam harsh or mean to you, it doesn't automatically mean that they are a troll. You may just be extremely sensitive yourself and have a very strong opinion about something that prohibits you from seeing another viewpoint. Sometimes just being respectful and seeing if they have meaningful things to say may change your original position

5. Don't spend the time feeding the trolls

While trolls can be annoying to an online platform or social media service, you shouldn’t devote too much time in dealing with them. Many times you could spend days trying to get your point across without any real benefit. Instead, continue to offer the best product/service available and building a strong online community. Even if trolls come around and stir up trouble, they can never take away everything you’ve accomplished and being ignored is one of the best solutions for malicious trolls, since few enjoy not receiving any attention. With the amount of great whales, dolphins, and chubby minnows, there is a good chance that a few clicks will silence hateful trolls without you needing to debate with them.

6. Reserve special treatment for supporters

This is not my own tip, but provides a good insight by Tera Kristen, “Special treatment is reserved for the people who truly support you and share your vision.” Tera recalls the time she gave a troll a second chance after they were banned from posting on a Facebook page. The troll apologized and went right back to spamming the community. Instead of giving this individual special treatment, Tera should have been giving her supporters this type of extra attention. Trolls are digging their own graves by choosing the way they act. I am in support of giving people second chances, however in cases like this, I don't feel a second chance is warranted unless a troll proves beyond the shadow of a doubt that they have changed their ways.

7. Trolls can influence credibility

Expect a fair of amount of bashing or debate from people whenever you discuss a controversial or unfamiliar topic. While some members of the online community can harm your credibility, that shouldn’t influence your standing on the platform. One of my favorite features about steemit is that you can bring up controversial topics like religion, abortion, politics etc and have a debate as respectful adults with differing viewpoint. Now that the reputation system has been implemented, the way you say things becomes increasingly important. That shouldn't keep you from speaking your opinion, but belittling, insulting or cursing at others is not beneficial in any sort of debate. I wish some of our politicians would also refrain from trying to slander other members, but politics is a hotbed for trolls. One may very well become president of the United States.

8. Young people are most likely to be harassed

According to a study by the Pew Research Center, "The 18-29 age demographic experiences the highest level of online harassment. In fact, 65 percent have been called an offensive name, been purposefully embarrassed, physically threatened, stalked, or sexually harassed.

The study also found young women experience severe forms of online harassment more than men, such as being stalked or sexually harassed." While I have thoroughly enjoyed my time on steemit, I was the victim of what I will call trolling. A user felt I was promoting another user for my own financial gain. This was not the case, but I was simply promoting the work of a friend whom I thought does excellent work consistently (@stellabelle). That user continued to claim I only wished to bing attention to work she has done so I may post on her platform in the future. I respectfully disagreed, but the user then went on to out me as a writer with a link to the secret-writer blog that Stellabelle edits and posts. I've gained a lot of confidence myself so for that I am happy to reveal that the article is here for those who wish to read it. She gave me the confidence to share something that I most likely never would have, and then to go on and reveal myself as the writer (along with Stellabelle's incredible photo and editing skills). The troll couldn't make me feel bad or take anything away from the work we did together. That troll now lives at the bottom of the comment feed and to see the comments made by them you have to intentionally click them. I'm not asking you to vote for the story I wrote, but I would like to let people suffering from any sort of mental illness that they are not alone.


9. Most harassment takes place on social media networks

Another verbatim quote "Harassment occurs mainly on social networks and apps. That same study from the Pew Research Center found “66 percent of Internet users who have experienced online harassment said their most recent incident occurred on a social networking site or app.” Other percentages of harassment on online environments include:

  • 22 percent mentioned the comments section of a website.
  • 16 percent said online gaming.
  • 16 percent percent said in a personal email account.
  • 10 percent mentioned a discussion site such as reddit.
  • 6 percent said on an online dating website or app."

If you have the stomach for it an example of disgusting trolling can be found here in the comment section Rebecca Black Friday The anonymity of youtube creates a place where normal everyday people have the ability to post the meanest things they can think of with little to no repercussions. While I am not a fan of this song, the amount of hate this young girl got for it shows the sorry state of many in our society.

10. The question of anonymity

As I just touched on before, people almost unanimously agree that anonymity allows people to voice things they would almost certainly never do in public face to face with that same person. There is less trolling in places where you picture and name are linked to your account (unless you create a fake account). Places like facebook and instagram tend to have less problems with trolling than sites like redditt or 4chan because of the ability to hide behind a simple username.

11. The law is trying to catch up

Law professor Danielle Keats Citron states “Hateful, offensive and distasteful ideas enjoy constitutional protection.” The perpetrators can be investigated or sued, but with each state having it's own laws about abuse on third-party sites, it takes a lot of resources to make lawsuits happen. An interesting read about a girl encouraging her boyfriend to commit suicide falls into a very interesting category as she was brought to court Article here. I can't imagine what goes through someones mind to follow through with this sort of despicable act.

12. Not all online systems deal with trolls appropriately

Many social media platforms are receiving negative press for the they handle trolling/harassment on their platforms. It becomes difficult to monitor all the content especially with social media giants like twitter and youtube. They have policies that show guidelines about what is allowed, but sometimes enforcing them is like playing whack-a-mole. Trolls pop up using different accounts and even the best intentioned moderator has trouble keeping up with cleaning up all the garbage that is spewn across many of the sites. I feel that steemit has set itself apart from the other major players with a few key features.

What sets steemit apart from other social media

  • Having a reputation system where if you troll people can downvote you into grayed out obscurity and force people to intentionally try to see troller's comments
  • The ability to make money. If a troll doesn't want to make any money here and is invisible I question what they are doing here

Steemit is truly founded by innovative creators in @dan and @ned and one of the first places that I have enjoyed corresponding in the comment section and have seen trolls be controlled and essentially purged (for now as they are a relentless bunch).

13. Trolls are humans too

Another example of what is possible with trolls can be read in the following paragraph. "As I mentioned earlier, trolls may have “Dark Tetard” personality traits, but you have to remember that they’re still human. Take what happened to writer Lindy West. After publicly discussing one of her cruelest trolls, Lindy received an apology via email. Not only did Lindy get an apology, this individual also donated $50 to Seattle Cancer Care Alliance, where her father had been treated. She even talked to him for over two hours on an episode of This American Life where he explained his actions.

While this isn’t always the case, you have to remember that we’re all human and can sometimes let our emotions take over. Heckling someone online isn’t the answer to making people feel better about themselves, but it does show that not all trolls are terrible all the time." It shows that even the most vicious trolls have the chance to change their ways, but it takes a lot of work on their part to regain the trust to be viewed as a valuable member in the community. Trust is built over a long period of time, but can be instantly broken.

14. Trolls can be costly

Whether needing to pay for moderators, or creating software, the process of rendering trolls voiceless is a costly endeavor. According to a 2013 study published in Justice Quarterly, cyberstalking victims cost victims an average of $1,200 due to “legal fees, property damage, child care costs, moving expenses, or a change in phone number.” The most costly trolls however are patent trolls (More about them here). The Harvard Business Review found, “patent trolls cost defendant firms $29 billion per year in direct out-of-pocket costs; in aggregate, patent litigation destroys over $60 billion in firm wealth each year. While mean damages in a patent lawsuit ran around $50,000 (in today’s dollars) at the time the telegraph, mean damages today run about $21 million.”

I have personally learned quite a bit about what makes trolls tick and also why they decide to do what they do. While I am glad that steemit has rendered many of the trolls here invisible, I would urge people to continue to treat everyone respectfully even if they do not reciprocate the same respect towards you. It is my belief that trolls tend to be lonely broken people, or those looking for an outlet for anger that has built up inside them. If you are a troll and are reading this article, I'd encourage you to share your story with the community. Chances are they will be quite receptive and you may even make a friend who has been through a similar experience. While I won't feed trolls or be provoked by their tactics, I hope as a community that we can reach out to all that are struggling or hurting and show a support that they may have never seen before. This may not be easy, as I have seen some pretty disgusting posts about people mocking rape victims or similar types of abuse, but hopefully we can find it in our hearts to be the bigger person and walk the high ground without an air of arrogance toward trolls. People are all valuable regardless of how they act. Hope everyone else learned something from this article too.

Sort:  

While I am grateful for what you have written here regarding your perception of internet trolls, I bristle sometimes at the usage of the word "troll" since it, like many labels, is often subjectively applied to find fault with or invalidate or otherwise put shame onto someone's differing perspective.

I'm not sure if you are familiar with the concept of Nonviolent Communication (NVC), but whenever I perceive someone saying or doing something that triggers me, I think to myself that the person is simply tragically expressing their unmet needs in ways that are unlikely to meet those needs. I don't want to put some people in a box labeled "trolls" since that creates certain unhelpful connotations that can cloud my perception of their humanity. If I lack the capacity in the moment to response compassionately to those whose communication does not meet my needs (understanding, compassion, respect, etc.), then I have learned the hard way through experience to remain silent and disengage until I can or simply move on, especially if it's just words on the Internet since they only have power over me when I focus my attention on them. I don't perceive verbal punishments through the use of shaming messages, ridicule, or moralistic judgments to be useful if I genuinely desire respect and understanding in the communication of others.

Also, I would like to add that it's possible to interact compassionately with those who have claimed to be victims of violence while still maintaining a healthy dose of skepticism on a site where such stories may result in financial reward, regardless of the veracity of such claims. Empathy and skepticism need not be mutually exclusive.

Thanks for your thought-provoking article.

Great comment. And you bring up a good point with the nvc. I also agree that "trolls" encapsulates far to many subgroups to pinpoint a specific behavior. This was as much a study for me about the thought behind the screen as an article about trolls. I wanted to put myself in a similar position and remove d myself that no matter what people say, everyone has value. Some people are harder to find that value in than those bursting with it, but we all have pain and hurt in our lives that we deal with in different ways. I appreciate you taking the time with a well put together response. I value opinions like yours, and am glad you found the article and what I added to it to be thought provoking. I'd love for many people to weigh in, but even just one good comment makes me feel justified in spending the time creating it. (I'm no writer by trade by any means so it is still slow going, but I like to make people think and smile within the same post if appropriate)

You're welcome! I agree that everyone has value that we can perceive if we take the time to understand them, even though some obscure that value through less effective communication strategies. I am grateful that I was able to provide you with one good comment. I don't comment often since I want to take the time to write something valuable, but you have encouraged me to write more in the future. Eventually I will get around to writing posts of my own and hopefully gaining more Steem Power to provide my upvotes with more value to you. :-)

As long as your comments add value through constructive criticism, humor, or engage the poster with questions, then I would advise you to continue to comment a lot. As a fellow minnow you can learn (and earn) quite a bit of knowledge and money through great comments. With comments you also don't need to think up an incredible post. I myself am still fiddling with my style of writing and learning each day. The best place for minnows is the comments section and to write some great articles and take feedback from those that comment to heart. Wish you much success!

I've written a couple articles on here so far about trolling:

A Toast: To The Imminent Decline Of The Nefarius Social Media Trolls (Thanks To Steemit's Bad-Ass Culture Of Character)...

Steemit's Cultural Standards: How To Deal With Sociopathic Trolls & Abusive, Potential Criminals...?

Such behavior is inevitable. However, I feel it's how we respond to it that determines whether/how it continues.

Sometimes, it may be wisest not to respond at all. Other times, it's an opportunity - to learn and to serve.

There's much growth to be had in ceasing judgement of somebody who's outright being an ass and being flexible (yet firm) enough to respond maturely and set a right example of acceptable behavior.

I think with the inbuilt incentivization & reputation systems on Steemit, the conditions here are greatly different than other social media sites - and the conditions serve well to discourage trolling to a degree. But even when they pop up, sometimes its an act of service the community to honor and respect them by taking the time to treat them fairly enough to engage in a mature conversation. Sometimes there's a gift for them in honest, direct feedback - which they need in order to evolve into contributors of value to the community.

though at the same time - time management...

I've tried that and have always attempted to be respectful and give people a chance to redeem themselves. One specific person really got under my skin as they went about degrading another user. I'm usually fine with whatever someone says about me, but I stand up for my friends. Probably would have responded differently now that I know a bit more about the psyche of some of those behind their screens. I don't believe anyone can truly be a troll without having some sort of deep wound or insecurity where they feel better about themselves by trying to take someone's emotions for a frustrating ride. Trolls will always be around, but I am willing to show them respect, even if they don't show it to me. While I don't feel trolls are an enemy I feel that this verse in Romans 12:20 rings true "If your enemy is hungry, feed him; if he is thirsty, give him something to drink. In doing this, you will heap burning coals on his head." Basically by being kind to those who show hate, you will make them think about what they are doing, because instead of reciprocating hate, you will have confused them and possibly changed a small part of their thought process. I will take a look at your articles about trolls as well, as I'm sure you went in depth and have some practical ways of how to best deal with different types of trolls and the best time to engage/ignore them.

I miss the old Trollcoin twitter bot. Whenever I'd get trolled I'd leave them a Trollcoin tip equivalent to the quality of their trolling skills with the message, "Keep on trolling have 15 trollcoins! " It used to drive them nuts! It would be fun to have something like that on steemit.

Haha starving a troll elicits joy, but seeing @berniesanders downvote a troll makes me laugh. Maybe you could bring a trollcoin back haha!

Thank you for the article. Everything is painted in detail!

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.20
TRX 0.19
JST 0.033
BTC 88885.90
ETH 3279.02
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.99