How does whaleshares differ from steem?
I was there in the early days of steem when there were just a few of us and everyone seemed to know each other. The rewards were greater at that time and there was an optimism in the air which was unmistakable. Something new and exciting had begun and we all felt proud to be a part of it.
The feeling today on whaleshares is similar, yet different. Open source facilitates the evolution of ideas and we can be in no doubt this isn't just a clone of steem. On the contrary it is something quite different and once more we can feel that thrill of being on the leading edge of thought in the field of decentralised social media.
During my research to discover what makes whaleshares different from steem I was surprised at how few people seemed to really have a grasp of this. There are a number of films on YouTube & DTube which claim to give us the answer, but in truth they only know the basics and have little information to offer us.
The most useful summary I have found is this recent whaleshares hangout:
The History of Whaleshares with Fuzzy
Since listening to Fuzzy speak I have felt a huge lift in my energy. It was the first time I had heard his voice and I can tell you he is quite an inspiring guy.
Who is Fuzzy?
Known on steem as @officialfuzzy (aka Fuzzy) he was amongst the first to sign up in April 2016.
He is the founder of BeyondBitcoin and the co-founder of Bitshares. He is also the whale behind the first whaletokens, whaleshares (which are mostly retired now and not the same as the wls we know and love today). Together with beyondbits these tokens were designed to work on steem to gain an upvote from his account there. These tokens represented a cross platform alternative to steem which were personal to Fuzzy but representative of a growing group who used them.
One could argue this is where the idea for SMTs was born, but uninterested in using the bitshares chain, Ned took the idea in his own direction by keeping everything on the steem chain.
As a reaction to some of the problems Fuzzy could see developing on steem he penned the whalepaper and whaleshares.io was created with his vision and guidance.
What were the problems he saw?
As the preferred distribution method steem was mined into existence and steemit Inc started out with over 70% of the stake. This created an uneven distribution of power right from the start and the situation did not (as expected) reverse itself, filtering the power down to those who were just signing up. On the contrary, the power kept on collecting in the hands of a few.
Those of us on steem are likely familiar with @berniesanders and the way he uses his power. Even writing his name here I have a fear that this article will be downvoted on steem... and there is something wrong with this picture.
Doesn't steem stand for free speech? If it really is free I should not be feeling fear.
My personal experience with @berniesanders has been minimal but there was one occasion when I was downvoted by a few of his associated accounts because I had written a post about he dangers of vaccinations which he had deemed inappropriate because the subject was being supported by a group of whales. He felt this to be unfair "reward pool rape" and therefore went out of his way to minimise the rewards for those of us who were writing about it.
This was mild in comparison to what other people experienced and I witnessed a number of people leaving the platform altogether after being targeted by him.
I have picked on @berniesanders as an example but in truth there are many who use the power of their vote to de-incentivise the coverage of certain topics, to make certain threads less visible under their posts or to simply force people off steem. Sometimes it is nothing more than a petty argument which would lead to a needless flagging war.
Further to this Fuzzy was also conscious of "circle jerks" who voted only for their buddies using automated systems and put his thinking cap on to find a better way.
Whaleshares.io
There is a feeling on whaleshares like we are on a level playing field, all of us equal somehow. Yes, we still have our whales and our community leaders, most of whom have been working with Fuzzy since the creation of that first whaletoken, but the number of high power rollers is very small for the moment and unlike on steem they don't represent a company but a group of social media users who are pushing together as a team to improve on that which has come before.
Fairer distribution of tokens
As the co-founder of Bitshares Fuzzy was able to sharedrop any holders of Bitshares the wls token to get the ball rolling. Any holders of the existing whaletokens were also rewarded with the new token. Other selected steem contributors were invited to the platform (like myself) sometimes gifted with whalestake from @nutfund to get them started. In truth the distribution is still happening as a large proportion of stake has not yet been claimed.
Decentralised structure
Around 25 pages of the 'whalepaper' are dedicated to explaining the problems with our current social media systems and the decentralised nature of this chain. I am not going to pretend that I understood all of it but I will tell you that a lot of effort has been put into eliminating those centralised aspects to keep us free from potential censorship and ulterior motives.
No rep numbers
The first thing we notice when we arrive on whaleshares is the lack of rep number after our name. What this says to me is that we have become accustomed to seeing it there on steem and we judge people based on what we see, consciously or not. Here we are all equal in that respect and there will be no more people calling me sir just because I am in my 70s. Which is great!
No autovoters
This forces us to manually curate and neatly puts an end to the circle jerk system. I have personally found it quite refreshing to manually curate after using an autovoter for two years and I can see how these strangers I vote for will almost always come and check out my latest post when I do, leaving me what they can with their vote.
An upvote is automatically a share
When we vote for a post, no matter how big or small our vote is, we are sharing the content into a separate feed on our main page for all to see. So, if we are going to build an audience here we must now become conscious that our followers can see exactly who we are voting for. Ultimately our voting habits will in the end define who we really are and our followers will act accordingly.
No secondary token
Unlike steem with its sbd and weku with its wkd, wls is the sole token of whaleshares and it is always rewarded directly as whalestake, accessible through the power down function.
No voting delegation
Not only will this put an end to the barrage of voting bots but it will help keep that playing field even. If you want to be a power player on whaleshares you will have to buy your way in or (as is the case for most of us) you will simply have to play nice and keep posting.
Extra cost of flagging
To flag someone on whaleshares costs three times as much as it does on steem and while this may not put an end to the petty flag wars but it will certainly make a difference. Fuzzy urges us to spend less time focused on flagging and more time focused on sharing.
If we don't like what someone is saying we can simply mute them.
Whalestake/vote ratio
I can't find any info relating to this but I can clearly see that my vote gives me more on whaleshares.
In my steem wallet I have 1,300 steem (current value around $1000) and my vote gives the equivalent of $0.06
In my whaleshares wallet I have 5000 wls (current value around $1000) yet my vote gives the equivalent of $2.84
A hefty difference as you can see and quite an encouraging one at that!
The power of your whaleshares vote can be quickly found in the bot-chat feed within the discord group by typing the following words, replacing my username with yours:
A big thanks to @alexpmorris for the creation of this awesome bot!
Central Discord group
Within the discord group we can post promote, meet other users and even interact directly with community leaders who will gladly answer questions for us. From what I can see @powerpics @krazykristina @freedomexists & @derangedvisions are all quite active there. Please forgive me if I have forgotten someone here.
As far as I know steemit inc has no equivalent of this group.
Whaletokens
Take a look at the current list of tokens which have already grown into existence through rudex which connects up with bitshares & wls.
Taken from https://whaleshares.info
To clarify, here on whaleshares we can create our own token (through rudex) and form our group around us by rewarding people with it as a way of thanking them for attending hangouts or producing great content. The tokens can be sold or transferred back to the user in exchange for their vote.
For more info on the process behind using your tokens in exchange for a vote, check "How do I send WhaleTokens to get a share/reward on my post?" on https://whaleshares.info
Fuzzy's intention is to help us create powerful groups which can collectively echo out a message across all the different social media platforms. He doesn't see whaleshares as being competition to the existing platforms but as a mechanism for connecting up with all of them to make our collective voice louder.
This is more than a big group of circle jerks, this is a family who look after each other.
"I grew up in a family that quite literally will give you more than they will take and if everybody is willing to do that then you can have a pretty amazing experience on this planet and not really ever need anything. I don't recall our family ever needing something they couldn't band together and provide each other. And that I think is a wonderful model." Fuzzy in hangout #9
His core message relates to the complete abolition of censorship:
"Has there ever been a time in history when censorship was the proper answer? Enabling conversation is what brings us closer together. The moment we start shutting off options for speech or people talking about things or doing things is the moment we start opening up a bottomless well." Fuzzy in hangout #9
He puts a big emphasis on the idea of sharing and supporting each other on whaleshares. Indeed, if we are wanting to make the most of our wls stake without autovoting we have no choice but to scan that NEW feed and hand it out to others.
"This isn't a blogging platform. This is a sharing network" Fuzzy in hangout #9
@derangedvisions had another way of saying it:
"This is a pimp your buddy platform"
Love it!
Whaleshares logo
The logo has been given a yin/yang feeling because harmony is what we seek and even when our independent voices might shout for different things, we must remain free to shout.
The whaleshares logo is not trademarked unlike the steemit logo which technically speaking we can get sued for using without their permission. Whaleshares artists are encouraged to enhance on the logo and post in the discord group, free for all to use. The fractal logo at the top of this post was found there. Big thanks to @cinelonga for your great work!
Final thoughts
I was invited to whaleshares by @alexpmorris and now that I have a better grasp on what 'here' is I am even more grateful to him for having given me an opportunity to be a part of it.
I have witnessed my whalestake increase at a staggering rate and there is a beautiful feeling growing inside of me like I might actually be able to achieve whale status here...
...and I sincerely look forward to paying it forward.
Read the WhalePaper HERE
Who is @samstonehill?
All content created for this account is 100% original (unless otherwise stated), produced by @samstonehill who invites you to use & share freely as you wish.
Sam is the creator of:
The Aspiring Steemit Whales & Dolphins group on Facebook which seeks to help newcomers make the transition from Facebook to Steemit, providing them with detailed notes and personal assistance with their posts... resteeming them when he can.
@teamsteem @timcliff @jesta @good-karma @someguy123 @blocktrades @pfunk @klye @krnel @blueorgy @ausbitbank @thecryptodrive @ura-soul @pharesim
This is a great write up compared to the others I've seen, but still some issues I have. First, it's absolutely a steem clone, not having a stablecoin and removing some functions doesn't change that. Second, to check to see if it was a true steem clone (I.e. a fork of the steem codebase), I went looking for the source code. Either they've hidden it well, with not a single result on Google that actually has code in it, or they're not open-source, since they don't even mention it or contributing in their FAQ. Absolutely a minus, wouldn't even consider joining this block chain without it being open source, and I'm surprised that it isn't, or isn't readily available in the FAQ. Third, while some of your the issues listed are almost definitely never changing (I can't see people wanting to get rid of reputation probably), most are possible. Anyone can suggest changes and push for them in the community, and just like you said, everyone thought steemit inc's share would decrease over time, you can't know what will happen with whaleshares. Steemit inc has at least proven to not be in it for just a cash grab. The devil you know & all that. Thanks for the write-up!
Posted using Partiko Android
I suppose technically speaking it is a clone based on the same source code but the way the tokens were distributed makes it so very different to steem. I was certainly under the impression it was open source? Can't imagine why they would hide it? Will look into that one! Thanks for the heads up.
I've been posting here daily and singing steemit's praises for over two years now (driving everyone around me completely barmy) and I'm not about to leave. I love it here :)
But I am certainly interested to follow the progress of others like whaleshares & weku too.
Only time will tell how they pan out...
Is this not the source code?: https://gitlab.com/beyondbitcoin/whaleshares-chain
Interesting, I saw that one but I discounted it because there's one contributor, no contributions in the past two weeks (and no master updates in 2 months!), and hosted on gitlab instead of GitHub. I also wasn't sure about the owner, but that doesn't really matter. Is that actually it though? One Dev, straight steem clone with barely any code diff? All the features mentioned in this write-up seem to be the only changes made, and as I said, the master branch hasn't been updated in 2+ months. That's a bit disappointing in general
Posted using Partiko Android
no, that is the source code.
Re-read what I said, I wasn't denying it was the source code (I did skip over it after checking it out when first looking for the source code), I'm just a bit disappointed with it
Posted using Partiko Android
I know. I was just confirming that thats the entire source code. With 1 dev working on it.
Not sure what they're working on now.
Oh okay, yeah I definitely read that wrong. Thanks for confirming that it is
Posted using Partiko Android
I think you may have overlooked the 2200+ commits in the whaleshares version of condenser...
https://gitlab.com/beyondbitcoin/whaleshares-web
Interesting, good catch, I saw that one but I discounted it because there's one contributor, no contributions in the past two weeks (and no master updates in 2 months!), and hosted on gitlab instead of GitHub but no CI/CD. I also wasn't sure about the owner, but that doesn't really matter. Is that actually it though? One Dev, straight steem clone with barely any code diff? All the features mentioned in this write-up seem to be the only changes made, and as I said, the master branch hasn't been updated in 2+ months. That's pretty disappointing in general
Posted using Partiko Android
Thanks for clearing this up!
why is this post hidden... I dont get it... feel sorry for you....
Got to protect your investment from the competition. Plain and simple.
You know it ;)
Not to worry. I expected this ;)
One person is behind the 8 accounts which flagged this post and he has perfectly demonstrated one of the problems on steem.
Lovely to see you again!
Perhaps you can try posting this on Medium.com too? You should know that the crypto community is uber-tribal and you seem to have stepped on a bear trap.
I'll read this without any bias but from my experience, any blockchain that doesn't offer any substantial improvements other than merely forking away with a community seldom work well in the long term.
But if there's more platform for speech, the better it is though. I guess. Harder for state players to subdue.
Thanks for the medium suggestion. I hadn't thought of that.
Isn't a more fair distribution of stake a substantial improvement?
I suppose in the end, only time will give us the answer to this question.
To answer your question, economics is like entropy. Money (value) will always actively seek to consolidate given enough time. Give a room full of people an equal amount of cash and days later 90% of money will be owned by a 1%.
Unless whaleshares can come up with a totally different tokenomics, give enough years can you'll end up with a top 10 accounts owning 90% of the coins.
I don't deny that Steem started out bad though. Those who knew of Steem early (and took the risk and expense to mine it) are now the large stakeholders you see around. I kinda just live with it now i guess.