Hey @radudangratian ,
Thank you for the contribution. I do not know if he wanted this but in my opinion icons have to be in harmony. I mean that, line thicknesses and proportions should be the same. These are most important things in Icon Pack Design.
As you can see below, I put the same rectangle on each icons. All of them has different proportions. Also, thicknesses are different.
However, you provided all requirement files for Project Owner and he is using your design already. Your contribution has been evaluated according to Utopian rules and guidelines, as well as a predefined set of questions pertaining to the category.
To view those questions and the relevant answers related to your post,Click here
Need help? Write a ticket on https://support.utopian.io/.
Chat with us on Discord.
[utopian-moderator]
With all the respect I have for the moderators, I think that this time there have been a few mistakes that can not be overlooked.
First of all, it is my 2nd contribution to this project, the third for this project owner and more than that, he chose me to work with him on his private projects. As he pointed out, if I was not "professional", he definitely did not choose to work with me outside the Utopian.
In the second row, there are 8 different icons with different design. You can not go over seeing this, saying it's only 1 design. I agree that the icons do not fit in well-known patterns. I never followed and I did not intend to fit in a certain pattern. Nothing is perfect and I'm convinced that anything can have a better version. I think that if we all fit in the same pattern, the world will generally be too monotonous. Apart from the examples offered by the moderator as "mistakes", I think with all the strength that what we have created does not contain major problems.
In conclusion, I say that I have never entered a public argument with a moderator, because I was one and utter respect for what they are doing for this wonderful community. But when I feel unmoved, I'm ready to take a step forward to tell my dissatisfaction.
I do not think I have the absolute truth and I do not want to be right if I do not deserve it. All I ask is that when a contribution is moderate to moderate carefully and be done correctly.
Thanks in advance and I hope I did not disturb anyone by this comment!
I think all points are valid and constructive. I dont know in what size are these cions going to be used, so its hard to judge the level of detail, but when it comes to unified look, they deffinitely dont look like one pack. Some are more complex, some use full shapes, lines have different thickness.