I really can't fault the Staniel Cay Yacht Club, because I didn't stay there for very long. I suppose it is down to personal preferences, but my own view is that if you're going there expecting some lush luxurious dinner, you might be disappointed. Especially if you've been thoroughly spoiled by the offerings at Atlantis. However, I really don't mind having a simple Burger and Chips for lunch, because the real fun came after!