My vote is very much for @bearone's

It is stylistic and gorgeous and full of meaning and symbolism!

Both good designs in their own ways, but @bearone's is the clear leader for translation into a silver round(imo).

I believe welshstacker's, even with digitization and simple modification will prove extremely difficult to translate onto a one ounce round size. If we ever make a 10 oz round....it can probably be worked into something ...and maybe even quite special.

Bearone's incorporates a lot...but in a manner that is elegant and pleasing to the eye! Here is hoping it is the 2018 Steem Silver Round!!