Protect yourself because no one else is going to.... Blockchains versus Palimpsests

in #steemit8 years ago (edited)

Most of us are used to centralized systems with a clear chain of hierarchy. When we enter this wonderful world of blockchains, we bring with us our expectations of security and safety. It's natural.

Yet Steemit is being marketed quite fervently to people on other centralized social media sites, to entice them with you "We pay you to blog". People are use to the Facebook experience, the Twitter experience, or their own personal blogs that are a palimpsest. A palimpset is a manuscript or document in which the original writing or drawing has been effaced, through scratching or chemical removal, to make room for later writing but of which traces remain.

Think of it as a chalkboard. This word harkens back to a day when writing material was scarce and hard to produce.
Your new users are coming from a chalkboard world where it is easy to edit, delete, and start again.

Steemit has been a wonderful introduction into decentralized systems for me. I was unaware of the potential for good and the potential for harm upon joining the site. No where in my introduction did it explain that what I wrote would be indelibly inscribed upon the block-chain. That there is no delete, no edit button. No one to ban a user who's harassing me.

While the freedom that comes with this technology is liberating for some, it may not be a good fit for a lot of adapters.

@smooth joined us in steemit.chat and cast much light on the subject for me. It was an awakening experience when they laid it out pure and simple. No one will protect you here so you have to protect yourself.

Me in my naivety, fresh off the programming of a centralized existence. I railed against this answer, as if maybe they hadn't properly understood what I was proposing (censorship, moderation, etc). Their frank honesty was freshing as they explained "look, it's not that I don't care, I do care, it's simply an inherent part of this system."

This flies in the face of expectation. New users should be met with a big red warning box upon setting up their account, or upon hitting 'post' about the rules of this new game. It's an alien concept to some of us.

Enticing, but also dangerous if not fully consented to. I urge the devs to consider such a 'declaration' of Steemit's inherent differences to other social media sites somewhere in the account creation. Make it clear and legible. I urge everyone who's marketing for Steemit to make sure you mention these inherent traits to your audience.

If transparency is law, then we should do everything in our power to make the inherent dangers of Steemit as transparent as possible as well.

images from http://www.texample.net/ and wikipedia

Sort:  

I tend to think some of the people are too technical for their own good.
While it is entirely true what is written on the blockchain is on the blockchain, that doesn't mean it needs to part of the steemit experience. We can see this with the NSFW hashtag. I can post anything I like and add that single hashtag... Because the site filters it out, it's not visible to anyone here.
Same with the mute button. It keeps you from seeing what was said, even though it in no way removes it from the blockchain.

There's a middle ground that can be explored.

Yeah! You are on the mark, where is my bullseye emoji when I need it! I'm all for pushing for exploration! That's why I keep pestering those with technical minds! However, until that's resolved with a creative work around, I think everyone should be informed about the "immutable technical laws" of this type of set up and the ramifications it can have for their user experience.

For sure they need to know they can't undo what they said. Absolutely, because it isn't visible to most doesn't mean it can't come back and haunt you.

For the trolling etc.... It can be implemented smoother was all I am trying to imply.

@clevecross That's really not how blockchains work. They record anything and everything without discrimination. The NSFW tag being filtered is a Steemit Platform issue. Not a blockchain issue.

Block chains were originally designed to be 100% immutable ledgers to act as historical records for finance. They work great for banking records, but not so well if you want to go back and delete a record because they make sure the current block must rely on the previous one by design.


  • Great for banks where you want 100% accuracy and consensus. Integrity of the information is priority #1.
  • Bad for use cases when you would all but kill for the "Delete" button in hindsight after a post.

Oh, by programmers for programmers? A lot of things that have to do with blockchain technology aren't build for human consumption, yet. Because the interface, design and whatnot aren't optimised for the common people, like Facebook/Twitter/etc.
A lot of thought has to be put into the whole thing before this is approachable to the masses. And since it is in their mission statement, they have to do something about it. And I really hope that steemit peeps understand it. Or at least some people who are building their own tools to interact with the blockchain.

At least a lot of people see the problems, and are offering their thought on what solutions may be.

Keep on Steeming

I agree 100%. Very good post. I am glad that know that others share similar observations!

Brilliant points. I think this should be a particularly important message for those that are trying to be deliberately harassing or otherwise abusive. The evidence is permanently there on the blockchain.

Thank you! I'd add that transparency works to reveal those who are trying to cheat the system with shady wallet transfers, and any number of nefarious activities.
We aren't use to such accountability in our lives!

nice... maybe call it the

RED PAGE

A must read follow up to those about to steem their life and or dignity away :P

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.17
TRX 0.16
JST 0.028
BTC 76556.14
ETH 2925.60
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.61