You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: What every user should know about the upcoming change in voting

in #steem8 years ago (edited)

The point is, people will now have the option to make a single vote worth more if they want.

No they won't. Once again, this is a fantasy that you made up and that neither you nor BP has provided any documentation whatsoever for, I already explained in the post above why that wouldn't be possible. You can not increase the total amount of P and not decrease the value o f each P. Not with a fixed reward pool.

I really, really do get what youre saying. Youve been spamming the same cooked fantasy all over steemit. It simply ain't so. Basically what youre describing is a system thats the same as the current one, but you can cast 8 100% votes on the same thing.

Again, i think this would be an awesome idea, but its not whats happening. And repeating the lie again and again isnt proof, its just propaganda.

It doesn't matter, if we're getting 40,000Px8 now, so is everyone else who casts a vote. P(sub A) will increase 8x just like P, and the two increases will cancel out. With a constant R and every P would be worth 1/8 as much as it was before in dollar value.

Sort:  

Just going to keep peppering my documentation around. This is the code change:
https://github.com/steemit/steem/commit/6500bb65eb6282866f3c6f356cbcbe09fd03c7bf

One wouldn't be increasing the power of total votes. You would only be enhancing the strength of a single vote at the expense of your future votes

I understand the fictional protocol that you made up. the problem is its not whats on the table.

Even if it were, it wouldnt work, at least not like you think it would. but its not

You made up a fake protocol for voting that not supported by any documentation whatsoever. I can't prove a negative. Your vote at 100% will still be worth the exact same amount of absRshares it was before the change. There is no 8x power vote. Its a complete fantasy.

Produce some documentation for it if you have any (you dont because you made it up) but you can't expect me to prove a negative

You're arguing points neither one of us has made, so that makes me think you don't understand.​

You can not increase the total amount of P and not decrease the value o f each P. Not with a fixed reward pool.

You aren't increasing the total amount of P because the voting power decreases accordingly with a higher-powered vote in the new system. Therefore, subsequent votes would be worth less due to significantly reduced voting power.

Yes, once again. I get it. Its just like the current system except you can cast 8X power votes. Thats an awesome idea that exists only in your head and is not documented anywhere except in a never past bed time land. This is where your vote is worth 8X

@sigmajin already knows this, but this is the code, which you can see has now been merged into master: https://github.com/steemit/steem/commit/6500bb65eb6282866f3c6f356cbcbe09fd03c7bf

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.16
TRX 0.15
JST 0.028
BTC 57978.54
ETH 2283.22
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.47