[South Africa Think Piece]~ White Genocide? A Black Perspective (My Personal Investigation Part 1)

in #southafrica6 years ago (edited)

#SouthAfrica Breakdown

I figured I need to take the next step in my dreams of journalism. I started looking into South Africa for a few reasons. One was that I can see many similarities in my country and theirs. The two are in no way proportionate in terms of severity of the social divide in the present day , but black inferiority and white dominance is still very much alive and a real factor of black poverty. I personally felt inferior as a child, but grew out of that mentality as I became a man and flourished in a multicultural land. I have plenty of white and mixed friends and don't hold a grudges about old views, but old views still dictate much of the wealth and social status of today. While doing my research on South Africa, its very important to keep this in mind; these aspects play a big role when getting to the next step in the understanding of South Africa.

Brief History

Apartheid-(a system of institutionalised racial segregation that existed in South Africa from 1948 until the early 1990s.) During this time there was a social scale in the order of White Afrikaans, Coloureds, Indians, and Africans. The Statistics South Africa Census 2011 showed that there were about 4,586,838 white people in South Africa, amounting to 8.9% of the country's population.

Nelson Mandela, a member of the ANC (African National Congress), abolished the remainder of the apartheid when he took office in 94", but how far has the country come since? During the past twenty years there has been a blending between the White Afrikaans, the Coloured, and the Blacks; or the supposed blending. I seems evident that the white population still holds the majority of the land and wealth, and civil unrest is on the rise.

Can You Blame Them?

The blacks are pissed, but whats new. The subhuman treatment, exploitation and pain inflicted upon the black culture was so catastrophic that 20 years later there is a culture still scorned. As the "Rainbow Nation", the people should be working in unison with multiple cultures to improve the infrastructure and quality of life, but as the U.S knows, old habits are hard to die quick. With such extreme poverty seeing such wealth, it's a slap in the face for many who live right outside their walls.

The one true difference is that South Africa has a Black majority where as the U.S has around 13% black. So with a black majority that is severely impoverished, and with a relatively short time span from the apartheid, the script has been flipped. When the views of Nelson Mandela were still fresh, he preached forgiveness and looked for options to move forward rather that seek retribution. With him gone and the rest of the society to interpret his vision, it seems things may be looking bad for the whites for once. I say "for once", because it is very unusual, if ever seen before, whites being oppressed by blacks. This is why I'm so interested in this piece.

Thought~

I'm a firm believer in Mandelas views and feel that for a nation to unify, there must be a level of forgiveness from the scorned to move forward. On the other hand, the black in me is oddly happy to see a dark skinned nation seek retribution. Its a weird feeling. I understand what needs to be done for the better of a population, but its about time there was a little payback for the whites who divided a continent. It is in this mentality where I can understand this generation of black nationalism. Is it the right mentality? No, plain and simple. Vengeance can easily lead to hate and civil war with more economic downfall. People must build upon the past and not stay living in it. Seeing as the white population plays a massive role in the South African economy, there must be a bridge for the gap.

Now The Real Story

Within the past 20 or so years, theres been talk about blacks reclaiming farm land from the whites. This has lead to a number of unreported murders of white farmers and seems to be increasing by some reports. With the government not responding and turning a blind eye to the increasing amount of murders, it seems like they are advocating the reclamation of the land. More than ever the whites are looking for support from their government who is turning a blind eye. This scenario is usually reversed in most black and white societies. From the outside looking in, it seems as though the government is letting the situation get out of hand so the white farmers will have little option but to sell their property. With the high level of crime and murders, the property value is no where near a profitable sell. Ultimately the white South Afrikaans farmer suffers and is left with little options for a future in the country they were born in.

Statistics

Screen Shot 2018-08-30 at 11.57.24 AM.png

Note~

While doing my research, the statistics produced by the government differ from the statistics of farm unions in the country. It seems that the police surveys take their own versions of polling to produce their statistics. Its a case of whether the government is unethically lowering the numbers or the people are politically raising the numbers.

White Massacre or Genocide?

Difference Between Massacre and Genocide~

As nouns the difference between massacre and genocide is that massacre is the intentional killing of a considerable number of human beings, under circumstances of atrocity or cruelty, or contrary to the norms of civilized people while genocide is the systematic killing of substantial numbers of people on the basis of their ethnicity, religion, political beliefs, social status, or other particularities. As verbs the difference between massacre and genocide is that massacre is to kill in considerable numbers where much resistance can not be made; to kill with indiscriminate violence, without necessity, and contrary to the norms of civilized people; to butcher; to slaughter while genocide is to commit genocide (against); to eliminate (a group of people) completely. https://wikidiff.com/massacre/genocide

This conflict would fringe on the border line between both. Nonetheless both would be considered humanitarian issues that need to be addressed. Are these issues supposedly not taking priority because they are white?

Farm violence has long plagued South Africa. In 1998 then president Nelson Mandela told a summit on rural safety and security:

"The government deplores the cold blooded killings that have been taking place on the farms in the past few years. While killings on farms, like crime in general, have been a feature of South African life for many decades, the incidents of murder and assault in farming areas have increased dramatically in recent years." Between 2001 and 2014, the country's human rights commission conducted three inquiries into human rights violations in farming communities, and in 2001 the police minister appointed a committee of inquiry into farm attacks.

As the inquiry's 2003 final report explains:

"Farm attacks may take many forms and can be executed in various ways. It can happen on any day of the week and at any time of the day or night. It can take place inside the house or outside. Many different crimes can be committed during the course of a farm attack. All kinds of weapons can be used in the attack, and anything of value can be stolen. Some attacks leave the victims unharmed, in other cases they are killed or seriously injured. Some attackers have a clear motive, others not."
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-04-05/fact-check-were-400-white-south-african-farmers-murdered-year/9591724

It is still unclear how many were murdered during the last 20 plus years, but what is evident is that there are murders taking place. The question about if it is a white massacre or genocide is still to be determined. Seeing as there is a mixture of race in these farm murders, its hard to label it a massacre or genocide. What is important to note, is that over 60% of the murders were white, seeing as they own more farm land than the other races.

The Police

What can I say, people have always had split feelings about policing. The problem with the police in this society is the massive amount of unchecked corruption and light penalties for criminals. There is near to no follow up with arrests and many criminals are let go from lack of paper work and evidence. For the police that are doing their job, it seems like a never ending battle with no help from their government. This is felt from the civilian perspective too. With these cases not being followed up on, civilians feel they need to take extreme action in defense of themselves and mainly rely on private security to protect them.

To compare, its in a lesser form like the problem the U.S had during the 80s and 90s in New York. Police corruption was at an all time high and it took major detective break throughs to weed out the corruption. Famous movies such as "Donnie Brasco" and "American Gangster" portray simulated and real events that took place in U.S society with the theme of tackling drugs and police corruption. This was no easy process and took decades of back and forth with little progress on handling the problem.

Private Security

South Africa has one of the largest private security forces in the world. At this point, private security outnumbers the South African police force. People rely on the swift and powerful responses provided by these well armed privatized forces. The problem with relying so much on private security, is that the money is going into the private sector and not benefiting the law enforcement infrastructure. With an unreasonably low police to population ratio, the police are contracting these private companies to assist them in normal and high profile cases. In many cases there is little governing over these private companies and atrocities have been reported. So if there is no control over the police and no control over private security, who is suppose to protect the South African citizens and infrastructure??

Conclusion

From all the information I've provided; my opinion has changed a few times while writing this piece. I started off thinking that there was a hidden massacre or genocide occurring with the white South Africans. As I dove deeper, it seemed that the media was trying to spin the story out of control. Farm murders are actually at a statical low. Yes the murder rate is still higher than it should be, but massive improvements have been made. I feel this is being blown out of proportion compared to the status of the actual country. These conditions that whites are being subjected to merely seem to fit into the statistical average of South Africa life. It could be that whites have always had their way and have not helped to improve their own infrastructure as South Africans and reduce poverty which would reduce crime. People are still largely exploited in the country and all South African citizens need to play an active role in improving their lives as a whole.
The reclamation of land was another issue when looking into the supposed white genocide. It is still unclear if the government is turning a blind eye to these murders. One can see for the reclamations political ventures, why the government would turn a blind eye, but the statistics show effort on a governmental level reducing the crime. There are many gaps and dark areas that I want to dive into more.
In conclusion I think it may just be a case of white people scared of settling with the standards they created. They created a nation state built upon the exploitation of others and now they are stuck in that society without governmental control.

Part 2 will dive deeper into the conflict and get more specific with the reasons for the economic status of the South African country.

I like to try to show my creative side on this platform so please enjoy the piece and leave a comment.
🤙🏾
Check out my previous post Here
&
Other Pics Here

Thanks for stopping by
@Popolo9thIsland

&

Instagram@ Questpic

Sort:  

This is an interesting analysis, I personally do not know that much concerning this situation but it is good to discuss the facts and see what happens.

I have studied this issue at length and can comment authoritatively on it. There is much I could say about the post in general, but to keep it short, I'll comment mainly on your conclusion - those obviously being the facts most pertinent to you.

Farm murders are completely out of control and are carried out with impunity and little fear of consequence. Attacks are extremely violent and are often carried out with little to no motive other than to kill. They are nowhere near a statistical low and are on the rise. Farmers are quitting and are moving abroad or finding other work, ultimately hurting the poor South Africans the most, blacks who rely on cheap staple foodstuffs to get by.

It is these same blacks who are kept poor, not by whites as you suggest, but by their own government. Never in your life will you have encountered such heinously evil politicians, corrupt beyond belief and interested purely in their own wealth, no matter the cost to the general population. Blacks are deliberately kept uneducated (please - investigate the post-apartheid education system in South Africa) and are fed political rhetoric which says: :blame the white man, blame apartheid".

Had political will been otherwise, the country could have been enriched and turned around by now (look at an example like Germany after World War II), instead the government increasingly steers the course towards a dictatorial and collapsed banana republic, while blaming everyone but themselves for their failings, this a quarter century after taking power.

Poverty reduction is out of the hands of whites and firmly in the hands of government, who actively steal any meaningful contributions towards it through nepotism and a uniquely South African process known as "tenderpreneuring". Other more blatant theft takes place when false companies are paid, entire project budgets disappear, or foreign entities like the infamous Gupta family simply siphon the national treasury dry. Add to this the effect that the various political and economic decisions have on their currency (the Rand) and Sotuh African poverty aleviation becomes a pipe dream.

The average South African wants nothing more than to live in peace and build the nation. But a government that sows constant divisiveness (look what they did with the Bell Pottinger campaign) seeks to actively create racial and other tension, for the sole purpose of keeping itself in power.

Crime is in no way reduced, do not believe government statistics which are manipulated or blatant lies. In fact, don't believe the official South African government take on Anything, including any reports form the state owned broadcaster (The SABC) or related media outlets like the Gupta owned ANN.

White Afrikaners (there are also many white non-Afrikaners in South Africa) created a system called Apartheid (meaning "being apart") which, while not a bad idea to state with, was horribly and extremely unjustly implemented. Blacks, Asians and "Coloureds" (mixed race) suffered terribly under it. Apartheid was abolished, but continues to leave a horrible legacy. But that legacy is nothing compared to what the current government is doing to it's own people.

Be very careful of your sources, I see a lot of government words and ideas in your post. They are simply not true.

Its nice to get an actual feedback. I was reading my post over again and I feel I need to clear up some spots. I felt a little insensitive of the actual murders happening. When I say "Blown out of proportion" I understand its not. Do you have any sources/stats that I can use in my next piece? I really want to get a full perspective and my mind and opinion always change if there is new substantial evidence to change it. Id love to ask you more questions about your knowledge on the subject. @bitbrain you a real one man 🤙🏾

Sources - tricky... does www.google.com count? My SA knowledge is like my crypto knowledge: gleaned over a long time from a variety of sources. I can't just cite a nice one-stop-shop where everything is available, such a thing does not exist.

But I wasn't kidding, I really do know a lot on the subject and I would be more than happy to help you. What I suggest is that if you have any specific questions or requirements, you reply to me / tag me (something that will show up in my "replies" tab) and I will get back to you with an answer.

To start you off again: I think that AfriForum (A South African farmers group) normally publishes pretty reliable stats on farm related things, including murders. Try https://www.afriforum.co.za/documents-reports/ for a start. Then don't neglect to Google other things I have already mentioned: The Gupta family, tenderpreneuring, The Bell Pottinger campaign to promote racial hatred etc. Add to that wonderful extras like the corrupt ways of recently booted ex-president Jacob Zuma (Try to get a copy of this book: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_President%27s_Keepers) , EFF madman leader Julius Malema, and all the anecdotes of SA ministers like these: Racist Lightning or Curing AIDS (a major SA problem) with garlic and beetroot. It sounds funny until you realise that these are the leaders of uneducated and uninformed masses who take their leaders at face value. If their "subjects" ever question their ongoing poverty, the ANC ruling party has only to point the finger at "the white man", hand out a free T-shirt or two (a remarkably simple way of buying votes when used on the very poor) and votes will be assured in the next election. Real issues like a major city running out of water (Cape Town) are ignored on purpose because it makes the opposing provincial party (The Democratic Alliance - also corrupt and evil, but not quite as evil) look bad when their city runs out of water.

You can't make this stuff up. Suffering people (of all colours) used as pawns... 😢

Im getting a split 50/50 view on the outcome of Zimbabwe's land reform. Whats your input on success and failure in Zimbabwe?

Ah Zimbabwe. I'm not a Zim expert, but I know a fair amount about it and fortunately I happened to be brushing up on it last month. I think that it would be hard to consider "land reform" in isolation with Zimbabwe. The land reform there was part of a much larger political game which has been playing out for decades.

Zimbabwe was a strange case: a former colony that broke away from its coloniser while still under minority rule. That gave it an extra "step" in the process towards fair governance that most other former colonies didn't have. There is no question that Zimbabwe once worked well and was developing into a powerful force, the old "breadbasket of Africa". Of course that development was done on the backs of the poor without sharing the benefits with them, in typical colonial style.

After Mugabe took power the Jubilation soon wore off. The man was a most despicable tyrant, one who has committed the worst kinds of crimes against humanity. He is the typical mad dictator: one who ruled by fear. He would build forces by kidnapping young men and boys and forcing them into his armies. These youngsters then faced a period of indoctrination. It's easy to control an army when you offer them the perks that most of society don't have: things like food and cigarettes. Women were similarly kidnapped to "service" the soldiers, a most despicable state of affairs. Under Mugabe everything was corrupt, rigged, threatened and dying - expect for those closest to him and his army.

The land was certainly redistributed as the farmers fled in waves. Each time he needed popularity another wave of farmers would be threatened. Cars of soldiers would arrive at a farm, tell the family that they had to leave now and just take over. The farmers fled to nearby countries and the farms went to ruin under mismanagement and apathy. Zimbabwe can now hardly meet it's own food needs. It will take decades to fix what Mugabe and his ZANU PF have ruined.

So sure. Land reform took place, but at what cost? Fortunately I have heard that Zim is inviting some old farmers back to their farms. After the harrowing experience I'm not sure how many will return, but Zimbabwe certainly needs them if it is to rebuild and feed it's starving population.

(Post-apartheid education system in South Africa)
this is a gold mine of info!
good looks

Yay awesome piece:) Wanna hear more about this xxx

Thx it only took a week 😂

Hello @popolo9thisland, thank you for sharing this creative work! We just stopped by to say that you've been upvoted by the @creativecrypto magazine. The Creative Crypto is all about art on the blockchain and learning from creatives like you. Looking forward to crossing paths again soon. Steem on!

This means a lot!! thx!
I need to put more effort in my writing, so hopefully next time the read will be more fluent :)
thx again @creativecrypto I'll post soon

To listen to the audio version of this article click on the play image.

Brought to you by @tts. If you find it useful please consider upvoting this reply.

Congratulations @popolo9thisland! You have completed the following achievement on the Steem blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

Award for the number of comments received

Click on the badge to view your Board of Honor.
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Do not miss the last post from @steemitboard:

SteemFest³ - SteemitBoard support the Travel Reimbursement Fund.

Support SteemitBoard's project! Vote for its witness and get one more award!

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.25
TRX 0.20
JST 0.036
BTC 94745.85
ETH 3468.48
USDT 1.00
SBD 3.48