A short history of Republican Tax Cuts compared to the Current Proposal

merrickgarland (35)in #politics • 7 years ago (edited)

Here is a short summary of the tax cuts and changes that have occurred since the "Reagan Revolution" and economic effects from them.

BACKGROUND

In the 1920's a Republican controlled government lowered taxes and permitted wild asset speculation. After the tremendous growth of the economy, and the first real indications that there could be a modern middle class, something went terribly wrong. The stock market crashed and the general economy soon failed, with estimates that as many as 25 percent of the work force was out of a job.

The crash occurred in 1929, late in the first year of the administration of Herbert Hoover. Republicans were telling us that recovery was just around the corner and that the federal government should not regulate markets, nor should it subsidize citizens directly. Little was done to repair the economy as the years ticked by.

Nearly three years later, Franklin Delano Roosevelt promised that he would intervene to get the economy moving again. Immediately upon taking office in 1933, FDR stopped the bleeding at banking institutions. But the road to recovery was long. FDR presided over a tenuous economy for years, but the Great Depression eventually ended.

After World War 2, the United States entered the modern liberal period where government would require progressive taxes where those who earned the most paid the highest rates, businesses were regulated, unions were encouraged, and in the later years, civil rights for those who traditionally were left out of the market were advanced. This period lasted about 37 years.

In those 37 years, standards of living rose. The economy was the best ever. Black people and women entered the work force. The American dream became realizable for many more. What had been tasted in the 1920's before the crash became a general reality.

In 1980, everything changed. After the 1973 Roe v. Wade Supreme Court decision permitting women to obtain abortions, an American religious sect became politicized. Until then, "Christian fundamentalists" believed in religion being the domain of God and not of politics. But in the next few years, this group of people re-entered politics with Jerry Falwell's Moral Majority and other groups supporting the Republican Party.

The 1980 election was a watershed. Just six years after Republican president Richard Nixon was forced to resign in criminal disgrace, a more conservative man, Ronald Reagan, won the White House. At the same time, Republicans won control of the Senate for the first time since 1958. The Supreme Court was already in the hands of a Republican majority, as the Richard Nixon/Gerald Ford period was able to appoint a majority of Justices.

This is where the pendulum swung. It swung hard to the right. Ronald Reagan was an ideological person who brought back the ideology of Herbert Hoover. In his first year in office, he brashly promoted oligarchy with what was then the most lavish inaugural ball in history. He set about immediately to tear down society with deregulation, sabotage of government agencies, threats and destruction of unions, and of course the first ever giant tax cut for the wealthiest Americans. During the Ronald Reagan period, he also deregulated banking, media, and allowed America's businesses to merge into giant conglomerates with extraordinary market power to control the economy.

REAGAN REVOLUTION TAX CUTS

The 1980's became known as the "Reagan revolution." Whereas Ronald Reagan came into office complaining about the size of government and the national debt, Ronald Reagan provided the first truly huge tax cuts for the rich, lowering the highest rates from 71 percent to 28 percent in two massive pieces of legislation in 1981 and 1986.

After his first tax cut, the economy fell into a severe recession, with unemployment over ten percent for the first time since the Great Depression, and the highest post World War 2 unemployment to this day. Tax cuts for wealthy people do not spur the economy unless there is demand for additional goods. Massive tax cuts for the rich would not provide such a stimulus, but the money would become available for other investments, pumping up stock markets, housing markets, and asset bubbles.

At the same time, Ronald Reagan's Federal Reserve squeezed the money supply so tight that it played a major role in the 1982 great recession.

But when the long recession finally ended, the economy was transformed. No longer would there be increased standards of living for workers. Fast increasing productivity would not be matched with wage increases. Workers would no longer gain based on the sweat of their own work. Technological benefits accrued almost entirely to the wealthiest people. This has been true ever since. We are still in the economics of the "Reagan revolution."

Incredibly, the net effect of the Ronald Reagan tax cuts was to shift a large chunk of the American tax burden from the rich to the middle class and even the poor. We know this mathematically by looking at aggregate numbers. In 1980, total federal revenues were 19 percent of Gross Domestic Product (GDP). By 1990, that number had not budged -- still at 19 percent. But along the way, wealthy people had their taxes cut from 71 percent to 28 percent, while a series of tax increases were thrust upon everyone else. The most significant one was the Social Security and Medicare tax, sometimes called the "payroll tax" or OASDI or FICA. Today, SSA and Med increased to 34 percent of federal revenues, whereas income tax dropped to 45 percent.

In 1986, the next phase of Ronald Reagan tax cuts came. They called it "simplification," but it increased the Internal Revenue Code substantially. The next year, the stock market crashed. The October 1987 crash was the worst one in history, and remains so. On a single day, it fell over 500 points or 22 percent, and it fell in the days before and the days after.

The next six years the economy was generally poor. The term "jobless recovery" entered the zeitgeist, describing a long period where official economic statistics were nudging upwards, but where people were not feeling the "boom." At the end of the Reagan/Bush period, the national debt had quadrupled, in direct opposition to Ronald Reagan's election concerns about the issue.

Democrat Bill Clinton came into office in 1993. Democrats once again controlled Congress. They wanted to restore tax rates. In August, a reconciliation bill passed the Senate 51 to 50, with Vice President Al Gore casting the deciding vote. The highest tax rate was increased from 35 percent to 39.6 percent -- still well below rates before the Reagan tax cuts. Republicans swore that this bill would blow a hole in the deficit and destroy the economy. They insisted that nobody would be able to blame Republicans for the projected damage.

Republicans were wrong. After a few years of moderate growth, the economy eventually boomed, topping four percent for a few years in the late 90's -- a rate not seen since the 1960's. Also, contrary to popular myth, the 1990's overall growth rate was higher than in the 1980's.

Just as the decade was coming to an end, government balance snuck into surplus. On the then-current trend, a 4.3 trillion dollar surplus was expected by the end of the next decade. We were out of permanent deficits and the fiscal house would come to order.

On December 12, 2000, a 5-4 majority of the Supreme Court intervened in the presidential election, stopping the vote count in the State of Florida, and handing the White House to George W. Bush on an official margin of 537 votes.

GEORGE W. BUSH TAX CUTS

Here is where the tax cuts really began. George W. Bush and the Republican Congress obliterated tax revenue, providing two bills over three years to cut taxes, strongly favoring the rich, and starving the government of revenue from then on forward. Unlike the many Ronald Reagan tax cuts that wound up being revenue neutral, the GWB tax cuts were true cuts. Total receipts fell from 20 percent of GDP to a low of 14 percent of GDP, then inched upward. Reports at the time said that GWB's tax cuts would eliminate the entire 4.3 trillion projected 10-year surplus, and turn it into a four trillion dollar deficit. This is exactly what happened.

The economy was poor too. Unlike in the 1990's when average growth was 3.7 percent, rates dropped to 1.9 percent on the 00's. Much of this sluggish growth went to income of the wealthy, or to expansion of government for the purpose of a series of wars that continue today. The remainder, some 2.5 trillion dollars of "idle money" lying around, went into creating debt and bubbles -- destabilizing the economy and eventually causing the huge financial crash of 2008. By then, jobs were bleeding rates hitting as high as 800,000 per month.

BARACK OBAMA CHANGES

Emergency stimulus and other changes by Barack Obama stopped the bleeding and began to reverse economic course. Just two years into his term, Barack Obama lost the Congress, which was replaced by a Republican congress that pledged to block everything and anything Barack Obama did, regardless of whether Republicans liked it or not.

The economy improved slowly over the next few years, and the deficit was reduced. The rate of improvement was apparently not satisfactory to a large number of Americans, who voted in a decisive minority to put "outsider" Donald Trump into the White House.

DONALD TRUMP TAX CUTS

Today, Donald Trump and his Republican Party are pursuing yet another massive tax cut for the rich. This one is a sort of combination of all the Ronald Reagan tax changed combined. This lengthy bill, somewhat secretive and piecemeal, provides major tax cuts for consolidations, corporations and the wealthy, leaving the "loopholes" for these two groups. The tax bill also promises a higher standard deduction for middle class workers, but eliminates preferences and deductions for those people. IRS Form Schedule A, the place where middle class people get to deduct medical, local taxes, mortgages, and more will be gutted.

The tax bill is front loaded. Workers receive tax savings up front, but these will be eliminated in a few years. Large businesses and wealthy earners receive benefits mostly right away, and these benefits do not phase out.

In the end, the current tax cut is more of the same: