You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Dunking on people!

in #palnet6 years ago

Sam’s notion that “bad ideas are being spread” is dependent on his notion of what a bad idea is, and he is a rabid partisan. So, I don’t think he’s really about confronting bad ideas I think he’s about making it look like his ideas are better in a format where he’s always the winner. I don’t think I’ve ever seen him concede anything with grace. He’s always very smug. Whenever I’ve seen him debate people he’s all about his side. So to say he he wants to confront bad ideas is just a touch disingenuous. People are allowed to disagree and It’s not up to Dave to debate Sam. Dave owes Sam nothing. That’s not what his show is about. He’s exploring himself through the format of a show. He’s had both left and right on his show. Anarchists, economists and objectivists have all graced his show. That’s what makes it interesting. Overall, Dave just wants to have a conversation and let us, the audience, decide for ourselves what we believe. I appreciate that in a world of media that wants to tell us what and how to think. His show reminds me of these really old shows where two people just talk about big ideas. Debate is great and finding the best ideas is important, but if that’s not the format of the show, so be it. There is no lack of “dunking” out there. It gets boring.

Posted using Partiko iOS

Sort:  

The only real critique I have of Dave Rubin is that he doesn't push back when he has a controversial guest. Granted, he doesn't owe me or anyone "confrontations", and it's important to make that clear.

His personal politics aside, which I tend to disagree with (like the usps/roads conversation) he seems like a civil guy, and as you clearly pointed out, his style of dialogue truly does not fit the Seder show or viceversa.

Yeah. I find it refreshing. People always want him to “push back” but that’s not his format. I love the idea that I get to listen in on a fireside chat. Just a couple of people shooting the breeze about a set of ideas. Then, if I want something more “debate style” or confrontational I can turn my attention to the other million channels that do it.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.15
TRX 0.24
JST 0.033
BTC 92220.01
ETH 2499.94
USDT 1.00
SBD 0.68