Mariah Carey Always Be My Baby October 10, 1995

It's not easy to hold the attention of an 18,200-person venue — let alone cause them to fall head over heels in love with you — but Mariah makes this look incredibly simple while serenading Madison Square Garden with a touching rendition of "Always Be My Baby." A decidedly more fresh-faced Mariah is at her Mariah-est as she points to the audience, throws up a "diva hand," tosses stuffed animals out to the crowd, and just generally looks way more energetic than we've seen her in years.