The Cost of Creativity VS Freedom to Flourish
"Creativity thrives in freedom, not in fear. When rules become walls and judgement a constant shadow, the spark of expression dims. True growth comes when people are allowed to simply be unapologetically themselves."
I have been MIA for five months now, give or take – I have OFTEN missed writing and sharing, but I have never been one for rules and my re-kindled enthusiasm for coming back to Steemit was promptly snubbed when I began to feel “restricted”. Nothing said or done to me directly, but rather to my son @judethedude… who was told very subtly that he would “be better off” if he did not share his blurt.blog details in his footer on Steemit posts. This REALLY rubbed me the wrong way! If anything, it made me want to flip the bird to Steemit and give my full attention to Blurt, as well as direct his there.
He is 15. A teenager in 2025. A boy. And you HAD him. He was writing 1000+ word “self-imagined” stories… WHY would you do anything to ruin that?! Make him feel scolded for such a trivial reason! It made my blood boil, because he came to me with it and clearly felt that his mother’s advice of “you just do you” – did not do! It was not good enough and it got him into “trouble”. He is no idiot, and as a relatively shy, contemplative child… he retreated.
If you go to ANY international business website - a professionally run one at any rate, they are going to have links to handles for every social media platform available... and they don't squabble with one another about who is using which and what!!
Lack of vision right there!!!!!
When I first joined Steemit in 2016, it was with excitement, hope, and passion. As someone who has always loved writing and has done so in many varying facets over my career, the idea of connecting with a global audience while earning a little extra for my efforts felt like a dream. I threw myself into it, dedicating years to building a very notable community – not just on Steemit but one which carried on to Hive too, after the fork. Yet, looking back, most of what I felt in those spaces was… unwanted. Especially by the “big fish” – because I had a mouth on me and I refused to keep it shut!
Let me be clear: writing is one of my greatest passions. It always has been, and it always will be. Nothing and no one can take that away from me. But every time I muster the enthusiasm to return to platforms like this one, something pulls me back. It’s like there are invisible eyes watching, judging, and imposing unwritten rules.
"You can do this, but don’t do that."
"Is this a quality post or a waste of space?"
"Are you engaging enough with others? Are you contributing enough?"
It’s exhausting.
To be honest, it’s not just the rules, it’s the money. Or more specifically, the way the money warps the culture. Thanks to a heads-up from @quirk-it, I recently read a post by @soulfuldreamer as well as the many comments and one in which I was tagged by @o1eh, and it all resonated a familiar bell. One of the many topics discussed… the question of why "lighter" posts… those that aren’t deep, intellectual, or groundbreaking, aren’t seen as acceptable. Who decides this? Who’s the judge and jury? And why does the fear of being “cancelled” for breaking some unspoken rule loom so large?
For years, people have asked why platforms like Steemit, Hive, Blurt, and Publish0x haven’t attracted the masses. Isn’t it obvious? It’s the money. With money come rules, obligations, and expectations – or at least that is the way it has been formulated by such spaces… (with the exception of Blurt, which has no “cancel” function) – Suddenly, writing isn’t just about expression; it’s about meeting standards, staying active, pleasing communities, and hitting arbitrary engagement targets. Compare that to mainstream social media.
Sure, you don’t get paid unless you are particularly popular… but you also don’t feel like your every move is scrutinised. You don’t feel like you’ll be penalised for posting something YOU WROTE twice, for not commenting enough, or for cashing out your earnings to pay for something (possibly dire) in the real world.
The bottom line? People don’t like being controlled. And every time I feel like I’m being told what to do, the passion to stay fades away. It’s not just about rules… it’s about the spirit of these platforms. Rules and systems that claim to foster “community” often feel like veiled dictatorships.
“Don’t share your Blurt handle here.”
“Don’t post on Hive if you’re not fully committed to the ecosystem.”
“You shouldn’t power down your earnings; that’s not what the platform is about.”
Why can’t people just be? Why can’t we allow writers, creators, and thinkers to express themselves freely, without the fear of being policed?
This is likely going to get me into hotter water than I already will be just by writing this, but I am of the opinion that these platforms claim to be different from mainstream social media, but in reality, the voting systems and hierarchies replicate the same dynamics. The only difference is the added burden of judgement and pressure. And frankly, it kills the spirit.
I came back to Steemit hoping for the freedom to write (and my son), to share, and to connect. But the reality is, the fundamentals haven’t changed. The structures are the same, even if they’ve been sugarcoated.
The way I see it… If we want platforms like these to thrive, we need to stop dictating. Stop creating rules that stifle creativity. Stop forcing people to play by arbitrary standards. The truth is, most people won’t join a platform where they feel controlled or burdened. And the endless crypto jargon doesn’t help either; it alienates newcomers before they even get a chance to dive in.
What I would like to see is a space where people could truly share without fear. Where a one-line post is just as valid as a 3000-word essay. Where your post doesn’t have to “contribute” to some greater community ideal to be appreciated, and the “outcome” of said post is left up to the people who see it and/or read it. Vote it, don’t vote it… share it, don’t share it… you know… like the rest of the ENTIRE social media world operates!
Not everything has to be groundbreaking. Sometimes people just want to express themselves, and that should be okay!!! Let people be. Let them create, engage, or not engage in ways that feel natural to them. Let the community evolve organically without judgement, rules, or pressure.
If that shift happens, I’d gladly invite other fellow Saffers to join. Until then, though, not so much – for the simple reason that I don’t want to invite people to a space that feels like a school classroom.
In closing and to be clear, I did not stop writing on Steemit because I wasn't "earning" enough. I stopped because I felt oppressed.
Do with that information what you will.
Perhaps I will write more, perhaps I won't.
Perhaps I will just share a pic of my garden or coffee when enthusiasm strikes...
Or, perhaps I will do nothing at all.
No matter to you... and it shouldn't ever be!
Cheers!
❤❤❤
Until next time...
Much Love from Country Bumpkinland, South Africa xxx
Jaynielea
ALL IMAGES ARE MY PROPERTY UNLESS OTHERWISE CREDITED
Typos make me human. I may or may not get around to correcting them.
All written content shared here is my property, unless otherwise credited
Now I know you didn't leave because of the money.
When I first signed up for Steemit, it was like a post-nuclear war world. There were tons of pointless posts that were only voted on by bots. For a long time, I had a hard time finding a place where I could interact with real people. Then I found the WOX community and got my first comments. Dozens of people voted for my posts, but they couldn't get more than a few cents. At that time, there were almost no people who had enough SP for their vote to be worth even 1 cent. Something had to be done about this, because Steemit was becoming more and more like a bot farm.
Then the Steemit team took the initiative, so to speak, went out to the people, and they started supporting dozens of good authors.
That's when the first rules and restrictions appeared. It was a forced step, aimed at growing dozens of accounts so that they could support other authors in the future. It worked, and now Steemit is much more interesting than it was then.
Having partially achieved their goal, the Steemit team has started to repeal the new rules. Look, no one is forcing anyone to be in the club5050 anymore. No one is obligated to burn their rewards anymore. There is not much time left and the platform will become as you described.
However, if you completely abandon the rules, Steemit will very quickly turn into a garbage dump of plagiarism and AI-generated texts.
No one and nothing will force you to do or not do anything here. So if you want to write another post, there will always be at least one reader waiting for you. 🙂
Hi there, girl! I was wondering what happened to you, and now I see. I’m so sorry to hear that your son was treated poorly! I completely understand you, and even though I’m new to the platform, I also find many aspects off-putting, very similar to what you’ve described. For me, though, it doesn’t feel like a classroom - it’s more like kindergarten. The strict requirements can feel overwhelming and demotivating. It seems like the amount of effort you put into a post doesn’t guarantee how it will be received - people either engage with it or they don’t. I, for one, rarely write anything under 50 words. I always make sure my photos are of good quality and write about things that excite me, things that bring knowledge or meaning! I think my posts are high-quality, but for others, they’re not. Posting things like shopping lists, basic selfies, or coffee-making routines doesn’t resonate with me (Here, I’ll make a note that I make an exception for posts written by Ukrainians - I’m sure you can guess why!) It’s totally okay for others, but I personally don’t find it engaging, informative, or visually interesting. For me, it’s important that at least one of these elements is present - knowledge or a beautiful photo. I thought that photos were especially important on the platform, but it turns out that’s not really the case. I also thought text mattered, but that turned out to not be entirely true either. This is where you and I differ because I haven’t noticed that “lighter” posts are frowned upon - in fact, quite the opposite. I wasn’t active for a while, but not as long as you. I often think that being here doesn’t make much sense. We’ll see how long I last and if my perception of the community changes. Best regards!
Preach it!
Timely as you always are, your words arrived precisely as I'm speculating along much a similar path... just had to significantly power down here to pay a stupid tax bill and I can't shake the uneasy feeling that I have become "persona non-grata" as a result of powering down... at least my previous support level seems to have dwindled to a pittance.
You may (or may not) that I used to rail against people going out in the world pitching Steemit everywhere as a place to make money... with (of course!) the attendant result being that 99% of newcomers cared not one whit for creativity and only about how to squeeze every last cent from their presence here.
Is it even about actual money? Or is it about a mindset that goes with a crowd that is money driven?
Meh...
Of course, it's not unique to the current generation of crypto-social content sites... everything — going back all the way to Epinions in 1999 — has been driven by 'whale politics" within all these myriad communities... Epinions, WrittenByMe, Squidoo, Bubblews, Helium, HubPages... the list numbers some 50+ failed ventures, these days.
I just want a place to publish my stuff and enjoy a modicum of engagement and community.
Well, anyway...
It warms my heart that you have found such a happy (I hope!) creative niche with your baking/sourdough venture! You ROCK!
Love always.
xo
I don't think anybody will/can/should judge/complain about how you blog as long as you do it on your blog or in appropriate communities.
I can vaguely recall a comment from a curator on your son's post related to Blurt. I'm not even sure if you are talking about that, but yeah, there was no need for it; they could have simply ignored the post if that didn't sit well with them. I understand how discouraging it could be for a 15-year-old. There's already a lot to understand and learn about steem mechanics, and unnecessary expectations can feel overwhelming. A common user doesn't care and mostly has no clue about the rivalry between blockchains; he/she is simply there for an experience.
I would have asked him to ignore and keep writing. The worst that could happen was less support from that curator; good content is eventually recognized.
Steem's much better now in terms of freedom anyway than it was 3 years ago. The main focus now is on AI and plagiarism. There is hardly any other issuable stuff. Don't feel upset and keep showing up, doing whatever makes you happy. We read you. 🙂
You tagged me, and what a pleasant surprise it was! Although I hadn’t reached out to you, I would occasionally visit your blog. I also came across comments from others asking about your absence from the platform and expressing concern for your well-being. It’s truly a relief to know that you’re safe and sound.
And as event-horizon pointed out, no one can force you to adhere to certain confinements except, perhaps, basic user etiquette or netiquette. So, why worry too much about it?
I’m not fully aware of what happened with your son, but I sincerely hope it hasn’t discouraged him from writing altogether. I hope he’s still expressing himself somewhere, writing his heart out.
As for my blog, where o1eh tagged you in the comments, yes, I was deeply reflecting and questioning why certain things were happening. There is a lot of context behind it. I had participated in a challenge and somehow felt wronged by the voting percentages and, at times, the lack of recognition, even after receiving the highest scores from the teachers. It really put me off, not because votes matter much, but because the percentages and their frequency sometimes seemed to reflect bias. But you know what? I have made peace with it. I will keep writing as long as it gives me something, somewhere, someone, or something to relate to, express to, and connect with.
So my advice to you: "You do you". As you advised your son.
Welcome back and keep popping now and then :)
We will read you!