Contest:Constructive Criticism and Ideas for Steemit.

in STEEMIT PAKISTAN2 years ago

You are what you bring to the table
The meaning of the quote stated above means, your worth depends on how much value you can bring to the platform through your content.

The quality of your content determines the value of your work. This is the pain point that i am going to elaborate in this contest.

Quality Content

IMG-20220828-WA0001.jpg

One trait that i think this platform lacks(to some extent) is the quality of the content, as compared to many other blogging websites(medium or blogger).

When i see people with low calibre content, literally below average, but being curated, it hurts, and i feel cringe about it.

image.png

Before criticizing about this loop hole, i wanna first share my experience, when i got negative ratings, a couple of months ago.
I participated in a steemit engagement contest, and expected to write a review about the downfall of cryptocurrency. I researched thoroughly and wrote a good piece of articles(writers are allowed to be little biased) and fulfilled their demands(I thought so back then).
But after reviewing my post, they gave me 0/10 rating, because i wasn't following any club. But i thought i was in club5050. Then i explained them why i wasn't, i had a genuine and technical reason, but they didn't bother. It was so heartrending.
I had bunker mentality back then, so i got defensive.
They didn't curate me not because of low quality of my content, but due to no club status(where i wasn't an offender). Now when i see people with good club history, and content of no calibre, but still getting curation, i feel this shouldn't be the trend out there

image.png

In @steemit-pak, the posts are usually about the diary games. In which most of the time, people share what they eat throughout the day(being a Pakistani who live only to eat, no offense to anyone). What they did, where they went. This kinda posts are tempting once in a blue moon but not all the time.

Speaking for myself, writing such things is like eating a cupcake. I tried to share such things, but couldn't continue, thinking what value this could provide to the people out there.

image.png

Then there are those people who get votes on their posts, they're growing their accounts, but what they write is not readable. Due to poor command on English and grammar. If we criticise such kinda content, they think we're letting them down for writing poor English. It's not their native language, they are learing and trying, which is fair enough.

But when you're doing it on an international platform for bloggers, and getting paid for your nasty content, then surely it is a BIG NO NO.

There is an option to write in your native language too, where you can do justice. Many reowned communities on steemit encourage to write in their native language, some even put this as a rule of order in their contest, to share your content in their native language too.

image.png

What is the good content then?

A good content has a large proportion of E-Educational element and small proportion of E-Entertainment.
It has following traits

IMG-20220828-WA0002.jpg

1.Educational / Value driven

A good content is the one, where people don't remain the same after reading your content. It adds value in their life, it must be informational. Like if you're sharing what you eat in a day, then why not educating people how to make it or bake it.

If you went on a vacation, rather than only sharing your pictures about food, mood and the location. Why not educating people and guiding them about the voyage. A bit history of the place,its people, its weather, food and its cost.

2.Crystal clear like a Mirror

Great content hooks the reader's mind and heart

A good content is easy to understand and relate. Such kind of content is written entirely for the limited audience(you can't write for everyone, Harry potter books are not for people who prefer romance or sufism).

A great content makes the reader believe that it's written only for them. Reader feels as if the writer is only engaging with him. It's like the desire mirror of harrypotter, in which he sees what his heart desires and wants to see.

3. Entertaining

A little bit of humor doesn't harm anyone

Rather than writing in a single boring tone, good content encases many elements like excitement, fun, sadness, and merriment.

There is a giant entertainment industry, which was built to amuse us. But i believe it should be done in limit. Entertainment once in a while is ok, but content based soley on entertainment won't add any value out there. Soon it will deteriorate the intellectual growth of a consumer.

4. Original and error free(Grammatically correct)

Great content is not a plagarised content, but the one which is composed without cheating. You can take an idea from others, but only those contents stand out, which are unique.

Also, it has no grammar mistakes. The moment a reader finds it, it literally damages the content and the credibility of the writer.

image.png

What is the solution for this problem?

  • The only solution in my opinion is not to give rewards to low calibre content, and warn the people to avoid cheating to do justice to this platform.

  • Every post should have ratings(great, good, mediocre and low content)in terms of written quality of the post.

  • Grammatical errors of every post should be scanned.

  • People should be encouraged to write in their native language, if they fail to meet the criteria for written english.

  • It must be mandatory for the posts to have more educational and informational element than entertainment(Ratio should be 2:1).

That's all for this. Hoping for you to read it.

Thanksgiving

@huzaifanaveed1

Sort:  

Of course you are absolutely right. With regard to German-language posts, however, I can only remark that they are often published far away from linguistic correctness, even in the native language. And if one is not proficient enough in one's own language to write without mistakes, blogging is perhaps simply not the right field...

Natürlich hast Du vollkommen recht. Bezüglich deutschsprachiger Posts kann ich allerdings nur anmerken, daß die auch in der Muttersprache vielfach weit weg von sprachlicher Korrektheit veröffentlicht werden. Und wenn man der eigenen Sprache nicht mächtig genug ist, um fehlerfrei zu schreiben, ist Bloggen vielleicht einfach nicht die richtige Sparte...

 2 years ago 

Thank you @weisser-rabe for sharing your stance on my post.

Absolutely blogging is about writing in the first place, and it is not for everyone.

We both have similar experience. It is sad to go through the stress of writing only to get swept somewhere beneath the carpet. I understand how you must have felt after taking quality time to do research and organise your work but didn't get curated for not being a part of a club. That is a sad. Well I hope this problem get fixed. Thanks to @@@huzaifanaveed1 for a contest like this.

 2 years ago 

Yeah, it stresses out when your quality work get negative remarks, but it's important to write good and follow the others rules like clubs, engagements and voting on others too.

 2 years ago 

Congratulations!

This post has been upvoted through steemcurator07

IMG_20220709_154455_053.jpg

Curated By - @fombae
Curation Team - Cosmopolitan

 2 years ago 

A wonderful post indeed! Now this what you call a usage of mind.
It's really important to try learn something first and then start getting benefit of it!

 2 years ago 

Yes indeed, learn first then inform others.

Good participation. You described very well. Best of luck dear fir your best result

This is so beautifully written. Thank you for taking part in the contest

There is an option to write in your native language too, where you can do justice. Many reowned communities on steemit encourage to write in their native language, some even put this as a rule of order in their contest, to share your content in their native language too.

I have stressed on this so many times that you're not obliged to write in English, nor anyone is forcing you to write in a language that you're not good in. Why not write in your mother tongue like the rest of the world on steemit is doing? For instance I see Indonesians posting only in their mother tongue, same with the Venezuelans. I'm not sure what's with writing in English? Is it because of inferiority complex?

Every post should have ratings(great, good, mediocre and low content)in terms of written quality of the post.

Hmmm, interesting. But who determines the quality of a post? Is it me, you, the steemit team, or anyone else?

 2 years ago 

I'm not sure what's with writing in English? Is it because of inferiority complex?

It's the upbringing of the society, which has damaged our identity as a Pakistani. Plus our educational systems is based on English medium for majority and urdu medium for restricted people. That's why people can't speak proper English or Urdu. They offer a mixed trait rather.
I think, community moderators can encourage people to write in native language.They are the authority here, so it's for them to bring, present, and implement new rules and ideas.

Hmmm, interesting. But who determines the quality of a post? Is it me, you, the steemit team, or anyone else?

Lol, steemit needs to manifest new software or robot to check the quality of the article.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.18
TRX 0.13
JST 0.028
BTC 56758.93
ETH 3033.46
USDT 1.00
SBD 2.30