How many users are affected by enforcing auth membership limits?
Current stable steemd version is enforcing auth membership limits.
How many users are affected?
The following link shows that the STEEMIT_MAX_AUTHORITY_MEMBERSHIP
is set to 10.
Each Steem account has list of account_auths and keys_auths. The first one is related to the applications you are using. Lists for each account can be seen on steemd. For example looking only at posting authorities:
Data for analysis was downloaded from SteemSQL using the following query:
SELECT name, posting FROM Accounts (NOLOCK)
Column posting
is a json containing arrays: account_auths
and key_auths
.
Let's look at the histogram for account_auths
and key_auths
, taking into account all the Steem users.
To be honest, the above histogram is not very readable, most of the values are on the left, so let's use the logarithmic scale. Now the chart looks much better.
We are most interested in the higher values, so let's zoom it.
From 5:
From 10:
From 15:
We can also check which exact users have the most account_auths and key_auths used.
Top50 by account_auths
. | Account | account_auths |
---|---|---|
1 | aneilpatel | 33 |
2 | hsynterkr | 30 |
3 | amico | 25 |
4 | anupbose | 25 |
5 | suheri | 25 |
6 | gilabola.mania | 25 |
7 | siol | 24 |
8 | cgbartow | 24 |
9 | bustillo | 23 |
10 | chronocrypto | 23 |
11 | nitro.speeder | 23 |
12 | dwiitavita | 22 |
13 | mkt | 22 |
14 | nulled67 | 22 |
15 | rye05 | 22 |
16 | birdinc | 21 |
17 | hungryhustle | 21 |
18 | jasmadiyunus | 21 |
19 | murizalpangeran | 21 |
20 | simplymike | 21 |
21 | pichat | 21 |
22 | buzzer11 | 20 |
23 | frankremmy | 20 |
24 | gamsam | 20 |
25 | nameless-berk | 20 |
26 | nikema | 20 |
27 | puregrace | 20 |
28 | teamhumble | 20 |
29 | amulla505 | 20 |
30 | jonnyla08 | 20 |
31 | sebescen81 | 20 |
32 | anzirpasai | 19 |
33 | ederaleng | 19 |
34 | jpederson96 | 19 |
35 | rishi556 | 19 |
36 | travelnepal | 19 |
37 | davidisfedup | 19 |
38 | viktorcapulet | 19 |
39 | samest | 19 |
40 | zainenn | 19 |
41 | szokerobert | 19 |
42 | tibfox | 18 |
43 | akintunde | 18 |
44 | barber78 | 18 |
45 | braaiboy | 18 |
46 | didic | 18 |
47 | evildido | 18 |
48 | inlakech | 18 |
49 | mermaidvampire | 18 |
50 | sinzzer | 18 |
Top50 by key_auths
. | Account | key_auths |
---|---|---|
1 | laodr | 23 |
2 | cn-reader | 16 |
3 | spaminator | 14 |
4 | steemcleaners | 11 |
5 | abit | 7 |
6 | lafona-miner | 7 |
7 | adm | 6 |
8 | delegate.lafona | 6 |
9 | juurop | 6 |
10 | spi-postit | 6 |
11 | ffbank | 5 |
12 | lafona | 5 |
13 | lafona-miner3 | 5 |
14 | steemiex | 5 |
15 | steempostitalia | 5 |
16 | robotq | 4 |
17 | guard | 4 |
18 | steemitblog | 4 |
19 | steemcleaner | 4 |
20 | bitshares.fdn | 3 |
21 | ceviche | 3 |
22 | cheetah | 3 |
23 | ginovotino | 3 |
24 | greymass | 3 |
25 | lafona-miner2 | 3 |
26 | sariel | 3 |
27 | steem | 3 |
28 | witness.svk | 3 |
29 | xeroc | 3 |
30 | ptgram-power | 3 |
31 | princess | 3 |
32 | quarry | 3 |
33 | alittle | 2 |
34 | aluma | 2 |
35 | amalia | 2 |
36 | anonymous | 2 |
37 | b0y2k | 2 |
38 | b0y2k13 | 2 |
39 | b0y2k14 | 2 |
40 | b0y2k15 | 2 |
41 | b0y2k16 | 2 |
42 | b0y2k17 | 2 |
43 | b0y2k18 | 2 |
44 | b0y2k19 | 2 |
45 | b0y2k2 | 2 |
46 | b0y2k20 | 2 |
47 | b0y2k21 | 2 |
48 | b0y2k22 | 2 |
49 | b0y2k23 | 2 |
50 | b0y2k24 | 2 |
Top50 by account_auths + key_auths
. | Account | account_auths + key_auths |
---|---|---|
1 | aneilpatel | 34 |
2 | hsynterkr | 31 |
3 | amico | 26 |
4 | anupbose | 26 |
5 | suheri | 26 |
6 | gilabola.mania | 26 |
7 | siol | 25 |
8 | cgbartow | 25 |
9 | bustillo | 24 |
10 | chronocrypto | 24 |
11 | nitro.speeder | 24 |
12 | dwiitavita | 23 |
13 | laodr | 23 |
14 | mkt | 23 |
15 | nulled67 | 23 |
16 | rye05 | 23 |
17 | birdinc | 22 |
18 | hungryhustle | 22 |
19 | jasmadiyunus | 22 |
20 | murizalpangeran | 22 |
21 | simplymike | 22 |
22 | pichat | 22 |
23 | buzzer11 | 21 |
24 | frankremmy | 21 |
25 | gamsam | 21 |
26 | nameless-berk | 21 |
27 | nikema | 21 |
28 | puregrace | 21 |
29 | teamhumble | 21 |
30 | amulla505 | 21 |
31 | jonnyla08 | 21 |
32 | sebescen81 | 21 |
33 | anzirpasai | 20 |
34 | ederaleng | 20 |
35 | jpederson96 | 20 |
36 | rishi556 | 20 |
37 | travelnepal | 20 |
38 | davidisfedup | 20 |
39 | viktorcapulet | 20 |
40 | samest | 20 |
41 | zainenn | 20 |
42 | szokerobert | 20 |
43 | tibfox | 19 |
44 | akintunde | 19 |
45 | barber78 | 19 |
46 | braaiboy | 19 |
47 | didic | 19 |
48 | evildido | 19 |
49 | inlakech | 19 |
50 | mermaidvampire | 19 |
If we sum account_auths and key_auths for each user then it turns out that 1161 accounts exceed the limit, which is equal to 10.
very interesting analysis. if the max is set to 10 how can people have more?
There are some interesting names above, it would be interesting to see some network clustering done on these based on auths. I wonder if it would be an early way to detect lets just say 'unfavorable' accounts
The constant
STEEMIT_MAX_AUTHORITY_MEMBERSHIP
has not been used before this change. And now it can be a problem.That's a great idea!
when has/will this change be implemented?
Congratulations @jacekw.dev! You have completed the following achievement on Steemit and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :
Award for the number of upvotes received
Click on the badge to view your Board of Honor.
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word
STOP
I didn't Know that I am the topper here. 😂😂
How do I disable these auths ?
you might find this useful https://steemit.com/steemit/@lolicorn/how-to-revoke-posting-permissions-for-steem-apps-via-steemconnect
Congratulations @jacekw.dev! You have completed the following achievement on Steemit and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :
Award for the number of upvotes
Click on the badge to view your Board of Honor.
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word
STOP