Maybe YOU should have this?!? (the three tiers of Mssr. Marples) Let me know if you want to get on board.

Me personally that is too fiddly, I will probably end up with a few different badges over time but they won't signify different levels of awesomeness.

My rule of thumb is if I am on a fence, I jump down on the side of not awarding. I find enough awesome content that I don't need to be sticking my badge on something that I am waffling about.