Are Computer Science Textbooks Needed Anymore?
Two nights ago I was working with my wife on her goal to introduce a computer science course of study into her high school. We ran into a problem when it came to costs, specifically the costs of textbooks. I had forgotten how expensive textbooks had gotten, even at the high school level. Now the schools do manage to buy math, science and other textbooks by utilizing long-term budgeting and planning. Trying to add a brand new course and finding the open FTE is one thing, but finding the budget for a whole classroom full of textbooks is a whole new problem.
So my big question to her was are textbooks even needed for high school CS classes? Intro to CS classes and Computer Science Principle classes don't even require textbooks. Right now Computer Science A requires a textbook, but does it really need one? This is not to say that students don't need references. In the age of a deluge of online tutorials are dead tree references the way to go? Teaching programming is best when you can manipulate examples. Being able to embed code examples that actually run and even have some be self-evaluating test problems is a huge benefit. Even if you don't make the websites dynamic, you can still cut and paste into your IDE of choice. Retyping from a hard copy seems the least efficient way to do things. Now I do acknowledge that many textbooks come with an online component, but I'm not sure if that is a point for or against dead tree textbooks.
Only two days after my conversation, I read the following on Slashdot: https://news.slashdot.org/story/18/01/31/1426251/high-school-computer-science-look-ma-no-textbook. This article provides a good review of the pros and cons of textbooks for CS teaching. I'm on the fence myself. Please leave comments if you have anything that might give me some more food for thought.
Now into my 3rd year of CS classes (first year in college), the only thing we have used CS textbooks for is the problems we need to code. Last semester, I didn't open my book once because the prof created his own problems. So my short answer is no.
Thanks. That was sort of the feeling I was getting, but it's nice to hear some confirmation.
Really great question for discussion. My opinion is that cs text books is no longer needed in cs classes. My reason being that the internet is filled with all sorts of cs and cs related materials.
Secondly I think Students love studying and staying online than studying in our conventional school classes, and it's also cheaper.
Also a good point. You are right there are a ton of resources available. The trick is to make sure they are organized and available.
Congratulations @rantar! You have completed some achievement on Steemit and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :
Click on any badge to view your own Board of Honor on SteemitBoard.
For more information about SteemitBoard, click here
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word
STOP