Final Update

今天早晨，巨蟹投出赞成票，改进后的工作提案正式通过。Bill 在Github上的README.md中，详细介绍了这一悬赏项目的工作模式。我已完成翻译并PR，今后也将继续为关于这一项目的双方技术讨论提供及时的翻译，并为中外社区更新此项目的最新消息。

This morning, @bitcrab finally voted "YES" for the modified worker proposal, which means it was approved. The detailed introduction of this bounty program was added to the README.md(https://github.com/bitshares/bitshares-ui) of Bitshares-ui on Github. I have already translated the README.md and waited for the acceptance of PR. I will provide Mandarin assistance for this project and keep both Bitshares community (West and East) informed about the newest progress.

Updates#3

Bill Butler 在telegram上提到：

我已经提出修改我的提案，为说服@abit和@bitcrab投票做出努力。我建议所有在Github的bitshares-ui这一项目上出现的问题，被指任为以小时计价的悬赏，每个社区成员都能够提交修改，如果他的代码被审核通过，就能得到这一问题的奖励。你可以看到@abit对此模式积极态度的暗示，但是没有最终回复投还是不投。(点此看最新讨论)

@billbutler on telegram:

I've proposed to modify the proposal in an effort to convince abit and bitcrab to vote for it. I've suggested that all issues, located at bitshares-ui GitHub be assigned hourly values and that anyone in the community could submit a fix, and if it passed, could be paid the bounty for the fix. If you examine this thread, you can see that alt hinted at a positive outcome to this but I have not yet seen a reply to my final question. By modifying the proposal in this way, it forces accountability in that only accepted PRs trigger a payment. https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php/topic,24755.0/all.html

Updates#2

@billbutler 愿意将此份工作提案改为发展基金，任何对UI做出贡献的人都可以获得报酬。需要进行项目管理和工作量评估，例如：修改一个问题，得到多少工钱。@abit 大神对此表示很有兴趣。期待进一步讨论^_^.

Quote from @billbutler:

What if we formally modified the proposal to state that anyone in the community could claim an issue and work it for a bounty.

For example, we could attach a dollar value to each issue and members could submit a PR and be paid the bounty amount for each issue. This would open the process to anyone who had the necessary technical skills to resolve the issue? Would this strategy allow you, @bitcrab, to support the proposal?

EDIT:
In essence, this would turn the worker proposal into a UI development fund.

Quote from @abit:

This idea is interesting.

A project manager analyse/classify the issues (as you're doing now), identify priorities, work with devs to identify what tasks need how much work/fund, or let the devs bid on the prices, after the work is done, review / merge to the code base (may need a team to do the reviews, may also need fund).

Periodically, report to the "management team" for performance review, but not only to an escrow who will release the fund no matter what's done.

Updates#1

对于中国人来说，15万美元是天价，我针对此说说自己的看法：

Indeed, for Chinese people, $150k sounds expensive, and here are my own opinions:

• bts是国际币，工作提案的薪资水平不能单单参考中国国情。薪资高，能吸引更多人才为比特股社区办事。国内朋友也欢迎写提案，我相信外国友人对于合情合理的提案也会投票通过。

Bitshares is international. The salary level of worker proposal could not only refer to China's national condition. The higher salary will attract more elites who work for Bitshares community. Chinese people can also propose a WP and I am sure that foreign friends will vote "yes" to the reasonable proposals.

• 外国友人欢迎公平竞争，国内大神也可以写这个提案，招木愿意象征性地收点费用，全心为您翻译，拿给国际社区讨论

Foreign friends welcome the open competition. Talents from China can also write a proposal about improving UI. I will spare no effort to help you translate it in English and hand it to the international community.(with a nominal fee, LOL)

• Github上的这一项目积累过多问题，而已经有一年没人管理，急切需要有团队不间断地维护进化，他们是第一个站出来的人。上次bts出漏洞，多亏比特股社区的努力和BM的出面，及时修补，但是市值也是闪崩了几个亿，还有不利于比特股社区的谣言流出。如若此项目没有人管理，出问题了，损失不会仅仅是几个亿。

This project on Github has accumulate a lot of issues and there was nobody who step out to maintain and improve it. Bill is the first person who stepped out. When Bitshares met bug last time, thanks to the dev group of Bitshares and BM came up and fixed it. However, there is still a lot of lost in Bitshares market value due to this incident. If there is nobody who manages this project and something goes wrong, we will lose more.

综上，这个报价可以接受。提案提出者也愿意开启对话，互相妥协。

In a conclusion, this price is not that unacceptable. Plus, the proposer is willing to open a dialog and reach a compromise.

想说说关于UI提案的事

  我加入比特股社区的时间不长，只有两个月，但已经深深爱上了比特股的一切：同行业内无法匹敌的技术优势，各尽其力的比特股社区。在这里，我仿佛看到了乌托邦的雏形。

I joined Bitshares community two months ago. It cannot be considered as a long term, but I just fell in love with everything about Bitshares : The unbeatable tech among all other blockchains and the Bitshares community, that everybody tries his best to make any possible contributions to. All the things here remind me of the prototype of the Utopia.

  最近一个关于bitshares-UI的工作提案被提出，让我更加明确比特股未来的光明。

Recently, a worker proposal about Bitshares-UI was proposed, which makes me more assure the bright future of bitshares.

  哈哈，这里面当然也有一些因为语言障碍，文化差异产生的小插曲。我最先在内盘圈里发出为这一工作提案投票的呼吁，却没有多加说明提案的具体内容，以至于国内很多大佬认为是工作提案是在骗钱。

Of course, there are some small incidents happened due to the language obstacles and the cultural difference between the east and the west. After knowing this worker proposal, I just could not wait to announce this information in Chinese Bitshares community, however, without a detailed and complete translation of this worker proposal.

  给人的印象就像是“居然要比特股社区花15万美刀的价格，供美国三个大爷吃喝玩乐，然后他们磨洋工，用6个月时间，做一个在中国三千块钱找外包，十天就能搞定的比特股钱包” 。

This leaves a wrong impression that, it costs you $150k to hire three western people from the Bitshares community who could spend up to 6 months to make the Bitshares wallet that you could get someone from China to get it done within 10 days for only 3K CNY instead.

  这里我先道个歉，没有详细翻译工作提案，就慌着来找大佬投票了，打扰了。

So I sincerely apologized for urgently asking Chinese big guys to vote without a fully-translated worker proposal, which is too disturbing.

  其实这个工作提案相当于是用15万美刀，雇佣一个美国的三人开发团队六个月，他们以每两周为一个工作时间，根据社区的意见，进行仲裁评估，修改开源在GitHub上bitshares-ui的这一项目发布的问题（这一项目已经积累了很多问题了），并为这一项目添加更多新的特性。（具体的还请各位大佬在百忙之中看下招木翻译的WP）而目前绝大多数的钱包（例如openledger的钱包）都是基于bitshares-UI的，并只做了少量修改，问题重重，bitshares-UI项目的进化迫在眉睫。一个官方出面进行修缮的bitshares-UI（相当于造轮子），能使未来更多团队开发自定义钱包时，快捷便利省心。

In fact, this WP is about costing $150k to hire a three-people development group for 6 months. Every two weeks, they review the issues published on the github, set some milestones to sprint , including adding some new futures.

(Please view the original edition of this WP to know the more specific working contents).

Currently, most of wallets are based on bitshares-ui (for example, OpenLedger's), and they only made a few modifications. The bitshares-ui has accumulated many issues, which should be modified immediately. Plus, making ongoing and official improvements for bitshares-ui(reference wallet) that are funded by bitshares foundation(like building a wheel), can make the third-party wallets development easier, quicker and more convenient.

  国外比特股社区最先对此的反应也是，工作提案相当模糊，而且竟然没有提到一个最终产品，表示不理解。后来工作提案的发起者Bill Butler，针对各位投票代理人的意见，做出了解释，并修改了工作提案，承诺定期给出界面效果的模拟模型。众位代理人看出了他们的诚意，也看其为比特股的发展做出过很多贡献，自身经验丰富，（其中@svk是bitshares-ui的长期维护者，billbutler是几大代理人之一）便投出了赞成票。

Initially, the response from the international Bitshares community was that, the worker proposal was pretty much vague, which did not mention a "final product". The proxies did not understand and did not vote. Then, the proposer @billbutler, made the explanation for their concerns and modified his WP, he made a commitment that he will give the mockup for UI. Proxies voted this WP because of his faith, his former contributions to the Bitshares and the team's development experience.

  工作提案的提出人又找到我，希望我能帮助他翻译这一工作提案，我看他想跟中国社区打开对话的迫切心理，欣然接受。（我象征性收了100bts翻译费，哈哈哈，请大佬不要怪罪我收人钱财替人消灾）

After this, the proposer found me, he wished that i could translate this WP into Chinese. I knew he urgently wanted to open a dialog with the Chinese Bitshares community and I embraced the offer.(I asked a nominal fee for 100 bts, LOL)

  翻译后，我再次大范围在中国比特股社区传播，越来越多人理解了这一提案的真正目的，开始投出了赞成票。

After translation, I broadly spread it in Chinese Bitshares community again. There are more and more people knew the real goal of this WP and began to vote.

  令人更加开心的是，今晚，我所钦佩的几位大神，alt，abit终于出现在国外tele的群里，愿意开启对话，进行意见交换。巨蟹大大更是在百忙之中抽出时间，在bitsharestalk的论坛上写了一长篇文章，说出了自己的顾虑，并愿意对话。
   请点这里看大佬们的讨论

It is more exciting that, tonight, the people I admire ,@alt and @abit, finally showed up in bitshare's telegram group and they were willing to open the dialog. @bitcrab spared his precious time writing an ariticle about his concern and he was also willing to open the dialog.
click here to see the discussion on the Bitshares forum

  招木真的是个微不足道的小人物。但如此积极地，自发为一个工作提案去做推进，是为了去中心化社区自治体系的顺利运作，它是我理想中的乌托邦。这一过程中，很高兴自己能充当一个桥梁，努力去消除中外双方因为语言障碍而产生的误解，让双方都能充分地交换自己的意见。也许中外双方的观点最终会不一样，但这么多人都是真心实意地为这社区积极努力，做出自己的贡献，且志向远大，目光长远。这一行业，未来可期。

ZHAOMU is just a little figure. The reason I actively and voluntarily promote this WP is to make a contribution for the successful running of self-governance of this decentralized community. During this process, I am so glad to be a bridge that makes an effort on eliminating the obstacles caused by language difference and cultural gap, to make Chinese and the rest shared their opinions freely and adequately. Perhaps the opinion about this will not be the same in the end. However, I see so many people trying their best to make a contribution to this community. They all have a huge goal.

  自己作为一个小人物，没有什么投票权，但能够跟这么多大佬直接交流，为取得共识共同努力，我真的倍感荣幸。

It is great honor for me, as a little figure, who do not have much voting power, but I can communicate with these big guys directly and try to help them reach a consensus.