You are viewing a single comment's thread from:
RE: ✅ BitsharesTalk Logo Design Entries - Help Us Choose A Winner - Vote for YOUR Favorite!
What. Really. Wow. That is really bad idea. Plagiarsm 100%
What. Really. Wow. That is really bad idea. Plagiarsm 100%
99% agree..
But his solution still an improvment of yours.. little but perceptible..
really bad situation..
cause it was my favourite..
=(
Thats is my second logo, the other option. If the owner chose B logo, they should choose me. Although I'm not sure that my logo will win, but I can't forgive the plagiarism!
When I saw them yesterday I was thinking about what you have already done :D Since I liked the B the most I was thinking that the curves were a bit overused, well to be frank I don't like the top, on yours the user was pretty much indistinguishable for me before I read your post, after that I can say yeah great idea :)
Anyways it's the way of the world, I did leave my comment above since podan was the one to respond to you first and I suppose I like arguing :D
It's a bad situation for sure, but I don't run the contest and I wasn't aware of it, I don't know any of you people so I can't say who did what, therefore I can't be certain it's plagiarism, the logo is really simple to make, maybe he got an idea from you, maybe he just converted the points to a curve ...
Either way I know your frustration, you worked hard on this, took your time for a week, thought about it a lot and you see the same thing posted by someone else ... the plus side is you get rewards from utopian, I'd say you are getting the better end of the stick in this situation, you were rewarded for your work, unlike manuel in this case.
I wouldn't call it plagiarsm, well not 100%. the designs are pretty simple, anyone can pretty much come up with it and I kind of doubt, well I suppose there is a chance, but really, I'd say it's probable ie. 20% to be sure it's 100% ... there are so many things to account for,
If we were judging by their works @naufal wins by a long shot, (I don't want to get into my opinion on your platform) sadly people aren't measured by their works but by opinions, so I can't say anything more because I don't know, there are many unanswered questions and you shouldn't be quick to judge.
well my thinking goes like this, there is a chance he saw the logo and did some minor changes, so that's 50% it's plagerism, but when you think about it the designs are quite rudimentary so I'd say probably, maybe maybe we can bump the odds to 30% :D ....
I don't know anyone so my opinion is pretty much drained on this point, here is another design that is 100% Not plagerised by your quick standards.
https://busy.org/@manuelcruz/bitshares-logo-concept-design
Is it not? Even not 100%, really? So I need to relearn about plagiarsm.
And, why do you mix the gravy in the porridge? Not related to. I didn't discuss the design links you provided. I have no problem with that.