I think that the concept of plagiarism in this context needs to be re-evaluated. Clearly, one post is in English while the original was in Bengali. The reality is that I rarely read articles written in any other language but English. I assume that most other people rarely read posts other than their own language. Additionally, the posts were made in two different communities. I can guarantee that I do not follow the আমার বাংলা ব্লগ community. However, if I wrote an article on how to cure the common cold, I am sure every community would be eager to disseminate the information. For that matter, if I did write that article and decided to repost it with the words "This is a reprint" emblazoned at the top, it would still be muted since the majority of the content was repeated.
I have been writing content since June 2017. While nothing rises to the level of curing a common cold, I have created a few things that I have found satisfying.
I created this image five years ago. None of the people I interacted with then are on Steem now. I can guarantee none of the people whom I communicate with presently have seen this image (it took me about twenty minutes of scrolling).
Perhaps a simple expedient of a tag #reprint (or some variant) could be used to designate auto-plagiarized content.
Okay. Thanks for your information, but can kindly tell me what you want again from this past issue which has already been resolved. What is your matter? After reading the above information I don't get what you want to the extent of even tagging the curators.
To focus on a single point:
If a post is written in one language and then written in a second language, it isn't plagiarism; it makes it accessible to a broader audience.
I agree, you are right, but... it would have to be marked at the beginning that the content had been reposted and the original link should be included. Then I don't see the problem. It reminds the situation when the content is shared on another platform and here, but without using #steemexclusive tag. Nothing wrong in it, as long as you inform about it others.
The problem is when someone tries to hide it. Reposting content between the communities does exclude from booming/SC upvote for that specific article. Here somebody got the SC upvote for the text which was already curated by another whale in the previous community.
Marking reposted article properly does not exclude regular upvotes though and is not against the rules. Banning for reposting (like in that case), if it's not made constantly, in my opinion is too much. Warning would be okay. It's up to the admins though, they make the decision and I respect it.
I think the mistake from the user here is he shared his old publication as a new post and I have investigated to see to it that this was just his first attempt in doing that. As a matter of that, we personally inform the user to desist from doing such a thing and as well as warned him from repeating such a mistake again. Thank you.
A proof of what I mean above is clearly stated in your own post which I link to that post below here.
Hello @anti-plagiarism, I just came active to see this comment from you, and I also testify to that the fact that he directly used his past post in a different community here as well which is termed as self-plagiarism, although self-plagiarism is less offensive but, I have given a warning to him and also tagged him with the plagiarism warning tag, I would be constantly checking on him to make sure he doesn't repeat such a mistake again. Thank You.
Sir it happened to me completely unintentionally. Because I didn't know much about it. Sir I have tried many times to replace the picture in this post but the picture has not been replaced. Sir please don't forgive me. I will not make such a mistake in the future.
Sorry for the delay. I will contact @papi.mati on discord so that he can provide me with the tool that allows me to see the self-plagiarism of a user taken from an old post.
I can't understand how to put such stolen content on the top list. Please publish the list carefully before publishing the list.
I have not pinned that post to the top list.
Thanks @ abu78 for the good work, while I was not on Steemit.
Without a doubt, we will be more attentive to this type of situation. Thank you very much to all!
90% of the content belongs to another sources:
https://steemit.com/hive-129948/@bidyut01/3e9uma-diy
@daytona475
@steem.skillshare
I can't understand how to put such stolen content on the top list. Please publish the list carefully before publishing the list.
cc: @ac-cheetah
@steemcurator01
@steemcurator02
Please note the matter a little better.
I think that the concept of plagiarism in this context needs to be re-evaluated. Clearly, one post is in English while the original was in Bengali. The reality is that I rarely read articles written in any other language but English. I assume that most other people rarely read posts other than their own language. Additionally, the posts were made in two different communities. I can guarantee that I do not follow the আমার বাংলা ব্লগ community. However, if I wrote an article on how to cure the common cold, I am sure every community would be eager to disseminate the information. For that matter, if I did write that article and decided to repost it with the words "This is a reprint" emblazoned at the top, it would still be muted since the majority of the content was repeated.
I have been writing content since June 2017. While nothing rises to the level of curing a common cold, I have created a few things that I have found satisfying.
I created this image five years ago. None of the people I interacted with then are on Steem now. I can guarantee none of the people whom I communicate with presently have seen this image (it took me about twenty minutes of scrolling).
Perhaps a simple expedient of a tag #reprint (or some variant) could be used to designate auto-plagiarized content.
I apologize for linking you folks to this, but I feel there needs to be leeway for articles like this instead of immediate expulsion.
@ac-cheetah
@steemcurator01
@steemcurator02
@daytona475
@steem.skillshare
@rex-sumon
@abu78
I agree with you. That's why I didn't enter the drama. The posts are in two different languages
Okay. Thanks for your information, but can kindly tell me what you want again from this past issue which has already been resolved. What is your matter? After reading the above information I don't get what you want to the extent of even tagging the curators.
To focus on a single point:
If a post is written in one language and then written in a second language, it isn't plagiarism; it makes it accessible to a broader audience.
Ohk. Thanks for your clarification. Yes, sure it isn't considered that was what I was trying to explain to the ac-cheetah. Thanks for this.
I agree, you are right, but... it would have to be marked at the beginning that the content had been reposted and the original link should be included. Then I don't see the problem. It reminds the situation when the content is shared on another platform and here, but without using #steemexclusive tag. Nothing wrong in it, as long as you inform about it others.
The problem is when someone tries to hide it. Reposting content between the communities does exclude from booming/SC upvote for that specific article. Here somebody got the SC upvote for the text which was already curated by another whale in the previous community.
Marking reposted article properly does not exclude regular upvotes though and is not against the rules. Banning for reposting (like in that case), if it's not made constantly, in my opinion is too much. Warning would be okay. It's up to the admins though, they make the decision and I respect it.
I think that is an excellent direction. I hope at some point the documentation around plagiarism will be amended to reflect that idea.
@papi.mati @rex-sumon
@milakz @daytona - please try to check the posts more carefully, we don't have enough power to downvote whole 37 USD from that sort of mistakes yet.
When I entered the community, that post had already been upvoted by SC02.
i will ban him from the আমার বাংলা ব্লগ community.
Thank you.
I think the mistake from the user here is he shared his old publication as a new post and I have investigated to see to it that this was just his first attempt in doing that. As a matter of that, we personally inform the user to desist from doing such a thing and as well as warned him from repeating such a mistake again. Thank you.
A proof of what I mean above is clearly stated in your own post which I link to that post below here.
Source.
@steemcurator01 and @steemcurator02
Wonderful craft, i sure know i will make a bird using your description.. keep up the good work.
Steem on
Thank you very much sir. Very nice comment after reading my post.
90% of the content belongs to another sources:
https://steemit.com/hive-129948/@bidyut01/3e9uma-diy
I can't understand how to put such stolen content on the top list. Please publish the list carefully before publishing the list.
cc: @daytona475
@steemcurator01
@steemcurator02
Please note the matter a little better.
Why is it plagiarism? 🤔 it belongs to the same person. Is it plagiarism to use your own photos in two different communities?
Do you know the meaning of #steemexclusive
This is not plagiarism post . it's a Repeat post.
Hello @anti-plagiarism, I just came active to see this comment from you, and I also testify to that the fact that he directly used his past post in a different community here as well which is termed as self-plagiarism, although self-plagiarism is less offensive but, I have given a warning to him and also tagged him with the plagiarism warning tag, I would be constantly checking on him to make sure he doesn't repeat such a mistake again. Thank You.
Sir it happened to me completely unintentionally. Because I didn't know much about it. Sir I have tried many times to replace the picture in this post but the picture has not been replaced. Sir please don't forgive me. I will not make such a mistake in the future.
This is your first warning and I would keep an eye on your subsequent posts if repeated you will be banned from the community. Thank you.
Sir, I assure you that such a mistake will not happen again in the future.
Sorry for the delay. I will contact @papi.mati on discord so that he can provide me with the tool that allows me to see the self-plagiarism of a user taken from an old post.
I have not pinned that post to the top list.
Thanks @ abu78 for the good work, while I was not on Steemit.
Without a doubt, we will be more attentive to this type of situation. Thank you very much to all!