✍️ The Priest and The Contest-Monkey - Episode 4: Plagiarism Reigns Supreme

in WORLD OF XPILAR2 years ago (edited)

Welcome back to another episode of "The Priest and The Contest-Monkey". It's great to have seen so many of you watch along with me and it appears that Steemit's awash with super sleuths.

Many of you have established who our protagonists are and Episode 4 will definitely confirm your suspicions if you've figured it out.

I wrote much of this post yesterday but I like to have a bit of fun along the way... so I left one of my "scammer predictions" in my comments yesterday. Once you've finished reading today's episode, have a look - I'm sure you'll find it 😀

If you're new to this story, Episode 1, Episode 2 and Episode 3 are still available on catch-up.

So let's get back to the story...

👇 Source

Separator-green.png

The Plagiarism Angle

One thing that I noticed across a number of these accounts, is their proficiency in trading. These people are absolute geniuses when it comes to reading charts, Relative Strength Index and Proof of Capacity.

And then it clicked - my little scamming crew might not be using appropriate hashtags but the original author might have done and then BINGO!

And that's where my multi-tag interface that I created came to the fore...

👇 My Screenshot
image.png
Separator-green.png

  • The Accountant - Relative Strength Index - Crypto Academy Season 2, Week 4 (May 2021)
  • Mary - Proof of Capacity - Crypto Academy Season 2, Week 5 (May 2021)

The pattern was there and there are many more examples. In yesterday's update (I wasn't planning to post so early but I got too excited), I was prepared to proudly announce that you should be looking out for a post about Trading with the MACD indicator.

But I was wrong. The next post was about trading with the SuperTrend Indicator, a topic so complicated that it needed to be split into multiple parts. "Written" by The Priest.


Update: The Accountant has now posted about the MACD indicator
Bb21BigBrother21GIF.gif


Whilst my prediction would have been wrong, I was relieved. Early seasons of the Crypto Academy were awash with scammers so there were over 100 entries each. By Season 5 Week 7, there were only 50 entering.

And as luck would have it - A formula was included which yielded a single identical match in Crypto Academy Season 5, Week 7.

👇 Source
Separator-blue.png

The Plagiarism Detector

But why didn't Google Search or a plagiarism detector pick this up? These people aren't complete fools - they apply for Community Curator roles with the knowledge of which tools should be used to check for plagiarism. I thought that they'd choose an old entry and translate it (maybe next time) but instead, they adjusted it just enough to pass the tests and included original screenshots (normally, but not always). Minimum effort - No suspicion. But they look like genius traders.

Somewhat bizarrely, this sentence was near the beginning with no previous mention:

SuperTrend indicator as I have said earlier is a trend-based indicator

and this is where the creative license comes into play. In probably the only original paragraph in the article.

The published article was copied from this post, written by a user who left the platform over a year ago.

👇 Source
image.png

Could they pass this off as their own work? Researched using the internet, just like the Academy Students did? Of course they could.

Is it different enough to constitute original work? The plagiarism detector doesn't detect it after all. But where are the references?

Could they claim Proof of Brain? I don't think so (I also don't think they did enough for it to constitute original work but we've all heard the arguments before).

Where's the knock-out punch?!

In their post about "Trading Crypto with Aroon Indicator", the level of dishonesty and deliberate deceit is all too transparent and any thoughts of "it's an honest mistake" can be abolished. The post concludes with:

Note: All screenshot are taken by me from the tradingview website were i perform my analysis from.

And knowing where they plagiarised this article from, why don't we do a little comparison? There are only 4 images to compare...

OriginalLiar
image.pngimage.png
image.pngimage.png
image.pngimage.png
image.pngimage.png

Oh, he cropped out the original author.

👇 Source

Separator-blue.png

My Fun Game

So as I mentioned before, I placed a prediction within my comments yesterday (25th May, UK Time) of what The Priest's next post would contain. Whilst I expected Part 2 to be the final episode, it appears that The Priest finds original content hard to come by so it looks like there'll be a Part 3. If we let them get that far of course.

I'd say my predictions were pretty good if not a bit too "copy and paste". The Priest wants to get away with it so I should've expected them to change the word order. If you feel like joining the fun, why not reply to my comment and we can see who gets the closest to the remaining 4 headings.

Separator-blue.png

What Next?

My hope is that support for this account is pulled, immediately and permanently. It would also be prudent to remove any outstanding steemcurator votes - there are certainly enough of them. And if any of you readers are in the Steem Watcher team, it might be worth getting the hungry-griffin to remove the votes too - my understanding is that they don't like plagiarists.

In doing so, I'd like to think that the other accounts will die with them - once the steemcurator and booming support is gone, what's the point in continuing?

Episode 5 will bring everything related to The Priest together, irrespective of whether they know about this mini-series or not. Including how I stumbled across The Contest-Monkey, who led me to The Priest (I've confirmed that the wallet transactions are as I'd expected) and where we are today.

I don't want to be repetitive but an episode relating to The Accountant, Mary and the fake accounts might be in the offing too. I just fear it will be more of the same (I could just copy and paste this post, change the word order and crop some screenshots and pass it off as an original piece).

image.png
👆 Source


👉 Continue to Episodes 5 & 6

Sort:  

DON'T... make your readers lose interest. We all know about it already. Don't shy away from the fight! Name the names. Boring? No, you will soon find new tasks! Very soon... 😂

 2 years ago 

I'm tracking quite a lot of names now... whilst some of them are "easy" after I discovered their plagiarism formula, others aren't so straightforward.

 2 years ago 

Friend @the-gorilla is playing Netflix's "wait for the next season" 😂, I won't change the channel.

That may be. But my chewed fingernails are slowly starting to hurt.... 😂

 2 years ago 

You should charge him for the manicure job for making you wait. 😂

 2 years ago 

I didn't think there were any nerves in fingernails... 🤔

These posts are certainly engaging, and they are certainly a challenge.

Looks like we might have a new Engagement Challenge !

All we need now are some prizes...

How about some nice sc01 votes for anyone who posts some winning names ?


We do need names and then sc0x, booming and hopefully @hungry-griffin can go about their business of removing votes as appropriate.

@abuse-watcher, @rex-sumon - are you following this closely?

 2 years ago 

How about some nice sc01 votes for anyone who posts some winning names ?

Gulp!

I’m 100% sure of The Priest because I’ve been able to find the original source of their crypto articles.

I’m continuing to doubt myself on The Accountant even though he’s doing the same thing because I haven’t been able to find the source yet. Same goes for Mary.

Having said this, we know that The Accountant plagiarised a Hive contest so it’s possible that they’ve done this before or since getting caught 🤔

Since The Contest-Monkey only does contests, I think their content is original. But the attempt to hide the transactions and the timing is highly suspicious - I’ve normally gone with this - I’m going soft. If there is collateral damage, maybe The Priest will think twice once people around him get pissed that their rewards dried up!

TEAM MILLIONAIRE

Congratulations, your comment has been successfully curated by @o1eh at 10%.

Looks like we might have a new Engagement Challenge !

Yeah, there definitely seems to be an avenue for gamification here. Maybe also some sort of scoring system and leader board? I'm on my cell phone now, but I'll probably post some thoughts in the next week or so if I find the time.

I have read all the episodes. If the representatives of a community or a group are dishonest, it has a bad effect on a large number of users. This issue cannot be taken lightly. Already some communities and many rewards have been lost due to various frauds. General users lose track and trust for them. Fraudsters work to gain trust first. Well anyway, I don't want to say much at this point.

I am waiting for episode 5. Hope we can see The Priest and The Contest-Monkey. We are very interested.

 2 years ago 

Greetings friend @the-gorilla.

I have come across plagiarized information several times that are not reflected in any plagiarism search engine, however, when these contents move in the same community they tend to be recognized by the mind as a sort of deja vu "Wow, I seem to have read and seen something similar" that's where you can do a scan of previous posts to that topic.

I find the track very interesting, I will be watching for another next installment of this mysterious story.



This Calculus is getting tough, I hope episode 5 won't land everyone in Abstract Algebra... and by the way this script seems to be extending to other adventures..., it might be interesting to see... THE END in episode5.

And that gave me Mary... who I had already guessed, but you have confirmed here.

 2 years ago 

I don't have the energy to go through all of that again with Mary and Joseph. It feels so futile to constantly fight the parasites - a post of yours that I'm very much looking forward to 🙂

This is a very wonderful episode @the-gorilla. You are doing a great job trying to clean up the blog and bringing to book some offenders. It's interesting!

The aim could be to correct the wrong and everyone will move.

I don't want to be repetitive but an episode relating to The Accountant, Mary and the fake accounts might be in the offing too

I am particularly interested in reading this episode as it has lingered. I think it is the right time to clear the air as some have some misconceptions. I believe it will make sense. Let's see how it goes because I can't wait to read and as well reply.

Coin Marketplace

STEEM 0.25
TRX 0.20
JST 0.038
BTC 94908.01
ETH 3553.53
USDT 1.00
SBD 3.80